Re:Alarming study shows massive insect loss
by hw_penfold on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @08:28PM
(#18234518)
I think the natural interpretation is that the January 1977 numbers showed a value 60 times greater than the January 2013 value.
(the dry weight of all the captured invertebrates)
Here's a direct link to the relevant graph:http://www.pnas.org/content/pnas/early/2018/10/09/1722477115...
Full publication:
Re:Alarming study shows massive insect loss
by lisper on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @09:37PM
(#18234950)
That would indeed be a not-entirely-unreasonable interpretation except for two things:
1. Why not just say that the numbers went down by 98% (i.e. 59/60)?
2. If you look at the graph, the numbers clearly went down by less than 98%.
This sentence made it hard for me to take the article seriously. What does a 60-fold decrease even mean? I understand what a 60-fold increase means: it means that there is now 60 times more than before. But it's not possible for there to be 60 times less than before for a quantity that cannot be negative. So we are left to wonder. Does it mean that there is now 1/60th as much as before? That is a peculiarly precise number. Is it really 1/60th i.e. 1.67% and not, say, 1/59th (1.69%)? Whatever the truth is, this sentence is obscuring it.
I don't mean to cast any doubt on the proposition that there is a serious problem here. This is a criticism of the journalism, not the science.