Re:The story of Augur, an Ethereum prediction market
by pavel_lishin on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @09:23AM
(#18229116)
> You aren't betting on who will win the 2020 election, you're betting on which answer people will converge on for the winner of the 2020 election. A subtle, but important difference.
To me, this undermines the argument that prediction markets are a source of truth.
Re:The story of Augur, an Ethereum prediction market
by flyingfences on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @09:58AM
(#18229386)
The thing with prediction markets, though, is that you're not just betting on which answer people will converge on. You're betting on which answer people will converge on, weighted by their confidence in their choice.
Re:The story of Augur, an Ethereum prediction market
by blunte on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @08:32AM
(#18228800)
Then I completely remembered it differently/wrong, and my comments perhaps don't apply!
I will review it again.
Re:The story of Augur, an Ethereum prediction market
by darawk on Wednesday October 17, 2018 @01:09AM
(#18236273)
Just to update, it seems my knowledge is also wrong, or at least, out of date. The way I thought it worked was an earlier draft, but they have some new mechanism that I haven't read about yet.
Is that a genuine question, or are you confused about the consensus mechanism? The answer to 'who says' is the core of what Augur is: people vote on what the outcome was, in a way that incentivizes them to vote for the answer they believe to be correct.
> So it's back to the original problem with smart contracts - you still have to trust an oracle, and I would bet ;) that if the stakes are high enough, an oracle will be manipulated in some way.
No, you do not have to trust an oracle. The whole mechanism is actually quite cool, you should check it out:
https://www.augur.net/whitepaper.pdf
> Let's take an election for example. We've had enough madness just in the US in the last 20 years to be skeptical of initially reported outcomes. In fact, some elections get reversed after study and investigation. Augur isn't going to reverse a funds exchange. And if someone has enough riding on an outcome, they may find it worth spending extra money to at least temporarily cause the outcome to match their bet. They just need to win briefly, even if the results get overturned later.
That's easy to solve. You simply define the question in a way that obviates those kinds of issues. In Augur, people vote on the outcome they believe is correct. The outcome of this process is defined as the truth, within the system. Since this is transparent, you place your bets with this in mind. You aren't betting on who will win the 2020 election, you're betting on which answer people will converge on for the winner of the 2020 election. A subtle, but important difference.