Ooh I hate it when people say that :)
In particular, it is a hackneyed journalistic technique to list the positions of the Left and the Right, deride them both as extreme, and then settle on a reasonable compromise in the middle.
A much better approach is to consider each idea on its merits.
In fact the threat to informers was manufactured -- the last drop was unedited and so far there are no reports of reprisals. And this drop was redacted to reduce the threat further.
On the other hand by hastening the end of the war and preventing future wars (by informing the public of the horrors), the upside is solid.
That's what I think. Instead of two strawmen, I would like to hear what you really think.
I think this war is unjust and unnecessary. US troops are nowhere near as evil as Nazis were, however, as the Iraqis themselves that commit crimes under US supervision are no match to the German counterparts in my extreme A.
Extreme B is evidently false. Trading a dictatorship for an invasion followed by chaos and civil war is not exactly a choice Iraqis would have made. Right now, I would oppose the withdraw of troops. Not before schools and hospitals are built, not before universal secular education and healthcare, from cradle to grave, are instituted and then about 20 years so that nobody will be willing to give up what they have grown up with. In the meantime, building a fair and competent set of laws and an enforcement system to match them. Then you may retreat and be sure that place will not collapse into an insane theocracy.
Re the 2nd, it turns out it's possible to build schools and hospitals without soldiers.
In Afghanistan, the price of every soldier could build 20 schools. In Iraq the ratio may be lower but, it's still a good swap.
The invasion of Poland was supposedly a counter-offensive to protect German civilians from Polish border raiders, too.
Germany had pictures of the dead bodies of the Polish border raiders in Polish military uniforms and everything.
> On the other hand by hastening the end of the war and preventing future wars (by informing the public of the horrors), the upside is solid.
Letting Iraq break into regional sectarian rule would be a disaster. Foreign forces need to be there until locally trained police and military forces are able to keep rule of law in Iraq. Letting the place become a failed state would be very bad for all parties involved from almost all perspectives - it would probably cost more American money and lives in the long run [1], and certainly would result in oppression, violence, and misery for Iraqis.
[1] If a country gets a reputation for withdrawing under pressure if wars aren't won fast, that encourages enemies during a conflict to fight a slow war of attrition, which is the bloodiest, nastiest, most expensive kind of war. Now, the response to this might be "well, America shouldn't fight wars any more then!" - but, realistically looking at America's history and demographics, I would bet on continuing to have an armed conflict every 10-20 years or so. Those will become nastier and more drawn out if the United States gets a reputation for withdrawing if an insurgency causes problems long enough.
reputation has little if at all relevance here.
The US largely employed a strategy of asymmetrical, anti-access, area-denial. shock and awe etc... in Iraq initial phase of the war.
put simply, we see you on the field we turn you into vapor, essentially making open conflict with US forces a suicidal idea, because you can never match the fire power.
This strategy, and not the reputation you talk about, is what encourages the enemy to fight an attrition, largely non kinetic war, over a long time, its simply a prudent logical approach to a fight against an enemy with far superior capabilities on the field
Parts of the military recognized this, and hence the COIN doctrine was born, wining the battle is easy for the US military, it is done swiftly. wining security post conflict (re occupation) is something the US military had consistent problems with primarily due to the size and nature of the occupying forces (20 something marines make a very effective combat solider, but lousy and impatient occupier)
Another way of putting it, is that the US does not need a great number of troops to win armed conflict scenarios, but require a great number of troops (of a different sort) to secure occupation, this was the point that general Eric Shinseki made at the time before congress, and was ridiculed for it by the neocon know it alls.
I do agree with you that the US will continue to have an increasing number of low level armed conflicts around the world, It is the fist of globalization if you will.
Another topic on HackerNews a little while ago asked what would our grandchildren find abhorrent about how we conduct ourselves nowadays. I bet you can see where this is going. Imagine all throughout history we thought slavery and human sacrifice was an okay way to conduct ourselves. What if someday our grandchildren's grandchildren come to believe that all war is immoral in and of itself or possibly say that an army should only be used for emergencies and defense. I'm not advocating this mind-set, I'm just creating a thought experiment that tries to {bracket} the dualism.
One more (to my mind) interesting consequence of concentrating on the initial intentions is that it is presupposed that the moral force is meant to carry through the entire event. "I did it all with the best of intentions" (Yes you did / No you didn't) seems to cover the duration of the entire event even if the event comprises many actors over many years. This arguably is not a great way of deciding right from wrong no matter where you lie on this issue.
And one more thing. And then I'll shut up, promise :) How people feel about this issue could be seen to stem not from the duality that I think was given but from simply how patriotic they are: I love my country / I am proud of my country / my country can do no wrong or rarely does wrong / my country operates with the best of intentions. Also seems to boil down to how trustful or distrustful of those currently in power or whoever is in power.
I hope we do find out and I hope we find out soon because I don't want my daughter to be having this debate with her friends when she is an adult about some other land torn apart by war. I say all this not in judgement of the current situation but to raise these issues so we can better understand ourselves. All things being equal (which they never are) are we at least in agreement that it is better this information is out in the open.
That the US installed, in a war justified by lies, or are we still looking for the weapons of mass destruction that could be used in 45mins?
The bigger idea was a domino concept; that a remade Iraq would be a beacon of democracy in the Middle East, that all the other states would similarly switch over (one way or another) to democracy, Muslim fundamentalism would no longer be a threat, and the whole region would be a capitalist wonderland with oil. Sort of like 50s/60s communism in reverse. But it didn't quite work out.
The disputability of the intentions of the war is something only American citizens question. Everyone else knew from the start that there was nothing good in it.
Just for a start, Google the matter for a few minutes and you'll see that the supposed evidence for the war was completely fabricated, and the Security Council received outright lies from the American representatives.
I think they really did expect to find a few fragments of evidence that would back up the "he's got a gun" excuse. I think they were genuinely surprised Saddam hadn't kept something going in private. But I don't think it was the strategic reason for wanting to go to war; an unrealistic and naive (but profitable) ideology was.
The ideology of the neoconservatives who fabricated the war was plain and simple: America must the be the world's superpower at all costs. This implies backup governments that are friendly to American interests, regardless of their political affiliations. There is nothing naive about that, it is simply perverse and disregards all concerns for human life or regional peace.
Just saying it's worth trying - just a couple of cities.
Anonymous throw-away logins are not supposed to be used for this.
They were at no treat what so ever to the US.
So claiming that the presence of bio-weapons in Iraq is some sort of a justification for invasion is just plain silly. If this was all that was needed, we would have invaded half the countries on this planet; many of them continue to be far worse than Iraq ever was.
In any case, the argument was based on the umbrella term "weapons of mass destruction".
You're right that as a justification, it falls far too short, even had it been true.
To compare what the US has done to that of the Nazis is the most unjust characterization imaginable. Obviously injustices have occurred but on a scale that pales in comparison to the the intentional actions of the Nazis. Please put everything in perspective. Look at the intentions of parties involved before you compare a freedom loving people to the worst example of political ideology in the history of the world.
It's hard to say either side in this conflict has the moral high ground, so it's equally hard to say that a move to the detriment of one side or the other is amoral (unless it's clear that a move is to the detriment of both sides.)
Despite facing them as enemies, I wouldn't even consider most of the Taliban, Sunni former regime elements, or Shia militias to be evil for trying to kill the coalition military; the only really evil things they do are attacks on civilian population, and that isn't even done by the vast majority.
In Iraq, we actually successfully reached out to a lot of the less-irreconciable elements ("Sons of Iraq") and gave them a role in the new Iraqi state. There were cases where one day they were engaging US forces, and they next day were recognized by US forces as a useful security force and given equipment (well, reflective PT belts from the PX, so we knew they were the "good" guys now) and support.
What would you think if we were in mid-1944 and these documents detailed the operations of Nazi Germany and listed several people who helped German occupation forces?
The morality of this war is at the core of this discussion. If you feel this war is immoral, then those who helped occupation forces to commit war crimes deserve no sympathy.
If, however, you feel the US liberated Iraq from a bloody dictator and the people who help US troops to combat insurgents while risking their lives are heroes, you will have a completely different take on this.
The truth, probably, lies somewhere in the middle. We may or may not find out.