Re:Snap, Flatpak and AppImage, package formats compared
by niemeyer on Monday October 15, 2018 @06:42AM
(#18218695)
Indeed the size calculation is incorrect. It's likely looking at the unpacked size, but snaps are never unpacked, which ironically is a difference missed by itself.
These are the actual sizes for these snaps:
$ snap info vlc | grep stable:
stable: 3.0.4 (555) 204MB -
$ snap info libreoffice | grep stable:
stable: 6.1.2.1 (86) 501MB -
$ snap info gimp | grep stable:
stable: 2.10.6 (47) 192MB -
Furthermore these metrics are amongst the least important when discussing "next gen" package managers. I am more interested in hearing about developer tools, sand-boxing capabilities, the update mechanism, OS support, private distribution, enterprise pricing. I don't care if one packaging system uses slightly more memory or whatever because of how it handles shared libraries, and if I do care I would still be interested in hearing what the trade off for that increased memory usage is.