E.g., "The top 1 percent paid a greater share of individual income taxes (37.3 percent) than the bottom 90 percent combined (30.5 percent)."
Ok, except this ignores the amount _earned_ by the top 1% (avg $678,359) vs. the bottom 90% (avg $35,083). [1]
And of course, higher wage earners are also likely to have disproportionately more wealth, as it's a lot easier to save, invest and otherwise maximize growth and minimize tax exposure when you have more cash available.
[1] https://www.epi.org/blog/wages-rose-for-the-bottom-90-percen...
Looking at tax rates in isolation is pretty academic in any event. The real question, I think, is: what are our competitors (France, Germany, the U.K., etc.) doing? Those countries tend to lean even more heavily on regressive taxes like mandatory insurance and retirement contributions, VAT, etc.
Up until it runs out, at which point nobody gets anything. And for whichever generation gets shafted (guess), they will be looking at a big negative when they see they get nothing for all the taxes they put in.
Now what could happen is one of two things. Either the benefits get cut to match the tax revenue at that time (estimates I've seen is that SS can drop to about 70% of what it is now), or that payroll taxes will increase, and the cap raised or eliminated.
There's a reason places with little to no taxation are flush with funds.
Places with little to no taxation are not flush with funds. https://www.taxpolicycenter.org/statistics/state-and-local-t... The generally red, generally low tax southeast and southwest states have about half the revenue per capita of the generally blue, generally high tax states in the northeast and far west. Where did you get this funny idea that collecting few taxes leads to collecting lots of taxes?
Investment is accelerating in low and no-tax countries or regions while it is waning in high-tax locations. There is a growing realization that silicon valley is not all it's cracked up to be.
Simple incentive structures explain a great deal of capital movement.
There is still plenty of activity in CA & NY on a sheer volume basis but the barriers are high, the types of businesses are shifting[1] in a detrimental manner and the overall trend is declining.
Don't get stuck in a purely domestic perspective. Absentee ownership is rising in many major cities due to international capital seeking safe havens for preservation of wealth - empty dwellings purchased at high rates results in elevated prices for working individuals, ensnaring them in a life-long debt cycle. If CA & NY continue resorting to taxation as the primary method for increasing revenue, they will end up like Detroit.
Rome's final collapse occurred over the span of approximately a decade and offers a glimpse at what is likely to occur: taxes became oppressive and property owners simply walked away because it no longer made financial sense - the benefits are outweighed by the costs.
How much more revenue loss can be endured by property owners in NYC before capitulation? They can hold out for a while and everything will appear to be doing alright, then the stampede begins and collapse takes place so fast you'll wonder what happened.
[1] https://www.citylab.com/life/2018/10/how-manhattan-became-ri...
Taxes across the board became oppressive in Rome - it was corruption that funneled funds to those who benefited. Not all wealthy are the same in their quest for control and power, or lack thereof.
Coinage records show a rapid collapse in the economy after a long period of gradual decay[1].
There is nothing new under the sun.
[1] https://www.armstrongeconomics.com/uncategorized/west-is-imp...
Your anecdote is one data point, nowhere near enough to draw conclusions about the entire state.
According to this source [1] in Fiscal Year 2016 income tax made 47.3% of federal revenue and payroll tax accounted for 34.1%.
I don't know what the exact numbers are if you take both taxes into account, but I do know that the headline [2] is at best grossly misleading because so many people are going to forget about payroll taxes.
[1] https://www.taxpolicycenter.org/briefing-book/what-are-sourc...
[2] "Top 3% of U.S. Taxpayers Paid Majority of Income Taxes in 2016"