News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Will cable TV be invaded by commercials? (1981) by dtech on Sunday October 14, 2018 @04:42PM (#18215194)
Apparently, Betteridge's law of headlines doesn't always hold up.

On a more serious note, it will be interesting to see if currently, ad-free on-demand services will undergo the same transition.

Re:Will cable TV be invaded by commercials? (1981) by codezero on Sunday October 14, 2018 @07:47PM (#18216323)
Amazon Prime includes “ads” for their own shows. I call them ads because they are on before the show I’m watching and I don’t want to watch them. Luckily, for now, I can still skip them.
Re:Will cable TV be invaded by commercials? (1981) by isostatic on Sunday October 14, 2018 @08:04PM (#18216394)
I thought I noticed that on an Amazon fire. It doesn't happen on my lg tv though.
Re:Will cable TV be invaded by commercials? (1981) by sjg007 on Sunday October 14, 2018 @08:06PM (#18216402)
So does HBO..
Re:Will cable TV be invaded by commercials? (1981) by wnevets on Sunday October 14, 2018 @04:46PM (#18215217)
Netflix is rumored to start advertising between episodes

https://www.cnbc.com/2018/08/22/how-to-opt-out-of-new-ad-tes...

Re:Will cable TV be invaded by commercials? (1981) by giancarlostoro on Sunday October 14, 2018 @04:59PM (#18215303)
It's not a rumor, they already do this. At least when you watch their original programs you see ads for more of their original programs. Thankfully you can skip them, they just try to show a trailer for one of their own shows / movies basically.

Edit:

I usually see it during the phase where Netflix is about to autoplay another episode, it tries to show it through then, I usually skip it cause it's stupid, I don't want to be fed the same trailer 500 times...

Re:Will cable TV be invaded by commercials? (1981) by jwatte on Sunday October 14, 2018 @05:50PM (#18215638)
I think there is a difference between "house ads" for other content, versus Nike trying to sell me sneakers.

However, I think that difference is smaller than most in house placement marketers think -- those I have talked to are genuinely surprised that I'd object to their own "programming."

For me, anything that tries to force me to take an action or spend (waste) my time or attention is an "ad" and is inherently bad.

Re:Will cable TV be invaded by commercials? (1981) by p1necone on Sunday October 14, 2018 @06:00PM (#18215709)
As far as I'm concerned they're exactly the same. I pay netflix so I can watch shows of my choice, if you interrupt the show of my choice with something that is not the show of my choice I don't really care what the interruption was exactly, it's just bad.
Re:Will cable TV be invaded by commercials? (1981) by giancarlostoro on Sunday October 14, 2018 @06:45PM (#18215988)
To be fair they do it at the end of a show, while the countdown happens, I can't say it's not the best compromise because it's genius, the countdown to the next show is plain but ad-free otherwise, my issue is seeing the exact same ads overtime. If something might be interesting to me, that's what your front-page recommendations are for aka "suggested for you" maybe a new tier "Netflix Originals Suggested for You" wouldn't hurt.

I'd happily opt for no ads period. Netflix should stick to advertising brands within their shows if anything, I don't mind in-show ads, as long as they're not too damn obvious. I was watching Bones once and they paused the whole premise to showcase a self-parking parallel parking car... Really?

Re:Will cable TV be invaded by commercials? (1981) by isostatic on Sunday October 14, 2018 @08:18PM (#18216445)
How about a compromise where I pay for a service and get it.

If they want to pay me to watch their advert then fine, pay me say 50 cents and I'll watch a 10 second advert.

How about that for a compromise?

Re:Will cable TV be invaded by commercials? (1981) by endorphone on Sunday October 14, 2018 @04:48PM (#18215225)
They are pushing their own programming (trying to encourage consumption of the programming that you already have access to and already paid for). I don't think it's fair to the conversation to compare it with the umbrella of commercial endorsements.
Re:Will cable TV be invaded by commercials? (1981) by wnevets on Sunday October 14, 2018 @05:50PM (#18215639)
Isn't how cable networks started and people made that exact same argument on why it was ok?
Re:Will cable TV be invaded by commercials? (1981) by endorphone on Sunday October 14, 2018 @06:06PM (#18215746)
I have no idea. I do know that the "something followed this path, therefore anything on that path is evil" argument is, and has always been, specious and a dead end.
Re:Will cable TV be invaded by commercials? (1981) by wnevets on Sunday October 14, 2018 @10:07PM (#18216929)
My point is why makes you think netflix won't follow the same path?
Re:Will cable TV be invaded by commercials? (1981) by tomhoward on Monday October 15, 2018 @04:35AM (#18218243)
One factor is that it's much easier to switch off Netflix (or any other internet-based streaming service) than it was (until recently) to switch off cable TV.
Re:Will cable TV be invaded by commercials? (1981) by maxerickson on Sunday October 14, 2018 @04:52PM (#18215250)
If you can't opt out of it it's pretty damn fair to make the comparison.
Re:Will cable TV be invaded by commercials? (1981) by seanalltogether on Sunday October 14, 2018 @04:56PM (#18215276)
It might be more fair to compare to public broadcasting stations. BBC doesn't have paid commercials but they do advertise their own programming between shows.
Re:Will cable TV be invaded by commercials? (1981) by endorphone on Sunday October 14, 2018 @05:01PM (#18215310)
Ignoring that you can opt out, if you can't understand the difference between information and advertising that is your own failing.
Re:Will cable TV be invaded by commercials? (1981) by p1necone on Sunday October 14, 2018 @06:07PM (#18215749)
Sure I understand the difference, but that doesn't make one better than the other.

Netflix interrupting what I chose to watch with something that I did not chose to watch is (in my subjective experience) pretty much equally bad whether it's information about other Netflix shows or an advert for breakfast cereal.

(Also is there an actual "I don't want to see these any more, permanently" option? Or are you just talking about the ability to skip each individual one manually?)

(Edit 2: also how is it not advertising? Just because it's advertising their own product doesn't mean it isn't advertising.)

Re:Will cable TV be invaded by commercials? (1981) by endorphone on Sunday October 14, 2018 @06:24PM (#18215859)
>Netflix interrupting what I chose to watch

Well no, they didn't. They put it between auto-play episodes. Auto-play, as an aside, is pushing an additional episode that you did not choose to watch. A preview of the next episode is a preview that you did not choose to watch. Both are about engagement.

>also how is it not advertising? Just because it's advertising their own product doesn't mean it isn't advertising

Their own product that you already have paid for and can watch at no additional cost, and at no additional incremental revenue for Netflix. Yes, they are trying to make sure that you enjoy the product and continue subscribing, but it's a world different from trying to sell you a chocolate bar or laundry soap.

These discussions on HN turn absurd because people like to engage in absurd rhetoric to engage in an emotional plea to exaggerate something. It's boring.

Re:Will cable TV be invaded by commercials? (1981) by p1necone on Sunday October 14, 2018 @06:28PM (#18215885)
What you're arguing seems absurd to me. Auto-play is just playing the next episode in a series, that is what I chose to watch.

I don't need Netflix to "make sure that you enjoy the product and continue subscribing" by making my viewing experience worse, when I run out of stuff to watch I'm perfectly capable of browsing the library myself, or looking up suggestions online.

Re:Will cable TV be invaded by commercials? (1981) by maxerickson on Sunday October 14, 2018 @06:10PM (#18215775)
"If you can't opt out" was a qualifier, not an assertion. I don't use Netflix and didn't research how the feature works.

The idea that the "information" they provide is not at all intended to modify your behavior is laughable.

Re:Will cable TV be invaded by commercials? (1981) by endorphone on Sunday October 14, 2018 @06:17PM (#18215822)
Okay, but your own ignorance isn't relevant to the fact that your spittle-laden reply wasn't relevant.

>The idea that the "information" they provide is not at all intended to modify your behavior is laughable.

Strangely I made no such claim. You're 0 for 2 now but strangely it doesn't stop you.

Re:Will cable TV be invaded by commercials? (1981) by radicaldreamer on Sunday October 14, 2018 @04:45PM (#18215209)
I could see a dual tier approach like Hulu. The ad supported tier is only $5 a month
Re:Will cable TV be invaded by commercials? (1981) by pacala on Sunday October 14, 2018 @04:45PM (#18215210)
Of course they will.
Re:Will cable TV be invaded by commercials? (1981) by chipperyman573 on Sunday October 14, 2018 @04:49PM (#18215234)
Possibly, Hulu already does this and Netflix is rumored to start doing it soon.

However, an important difference between old TV and current-day streaming is that it is much easier to pirate shows that are streaming. There is an (ad-)free alternative to Hulu and Netflix that is becoming easier to use. At some point, streaming services may have to compete by not including ads.

Re:Will cable TV be invaded by commercials? (1981) by jlg23 on Sunday October 14, 2018 @05:02PM (#18215315)
> However, an important difference between old TV and current-day streaming is that it is much easier to pirate shows that are streaming.

As someone who grew up recording (and distributing to friends) one-to-many streams (a.k.a. terrestrial TV), I wonder how it got easier. Just because nobody is using personalized watermarks to prove copyright infringement yet, does not mean a redistributor today ain't going to get sued tomorrow.

Re:Will cable TV be invaded by commercials? (1981) by icebraining on Sunday October 14, 2018 @05:31PM (#18215494)
You can create an account with gift cards paid in cash, so I wish them good luck.
Re:Will cable TV be invaded by commercials? (1981) by jlg23 on Sunday October 14, 2018 @06:04PM (#18215731)
In the US. Good luck in other countries[1].

[1] I've been to much more countries where the currency of choice is top-up cards for mobile phones. Master- and VISA-cards issued by local banks are usually only usable for national transactions - not to speak of gift cards, which just don't exist.

Re:Will cable TV be invaded by commercials? (1981) by icebraining on Sunday October 14, 2018 @07:01PM (#18216068)
I'm not talking about Master/VISA gift cards, I'm talking about Netflix gift cards. I'm not in the US, yet they are readily available.

According to [1], they seem to be available at least in the US, Canada, Australia, many European countries, Brazil, Malaysia and Japan. That's far from the whole world, but quite enough as a source of potential pirates.

[1] https://help.netflix.com/en/node/32950/br

Re:Will cable TV be invaded by commercials? (1981) by p1necone on Sunday October 14, 2018 @06:11PM (#18215777)
In New Zealand you can buy prepaid credit cards with cash (and no personal information) that work anywhere visa/mastercard is accepted afaik.
Re:Will cable TV be invaded by commercials? (1981) by kbenson on Sunday October 14, 2018 @05:08PM (#18215345)
Hulu/Hulu Plus always advertised. I was very excited a year or two ago when they finally offered ad-free streaming for an additional few dollars.
Re:Will cable TV be invaded by commercials? (1981) by Spooky23 on Sunday October 14, 2018 @05:54PM (#18215669)
I was surprised that it took so long, those ads are not very valuable.

My beef with Hulu wasn’t that there were ads, it was that there was one ad. I think it was Tampax Pearls when I was watching.

I’m at the same point with MLB.tv. I get nauseous every time I hear about Pudge Rodriguez’s journey to Cooperstown thanks to Bank of America visa or the all new Chevy Traverse and its collection of JD Power awards.

Re:Will cable TV be invaded by commercials? (1981) by sjg007 on Sunday October 14, 2018 @08:09PM (#18216408)
It's kind of weird when the don't have ads and the skip to the MLB will be right back screen.. You realize how many ads a baseball has. It's not like they show the warm up for the inning or anything or the 7th inning stretch.. nope just blank. I'd appreciate an MLB service that actually just kept playing through that.