News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Battered Yahoo Admits It Overplayed Hand; Open To New Mic... by sabat on Monday May 05, 2008 @11:25PM (#182142)
I guess this is part of 'business' that I'll never understand. Why on Earth is it that Yahoo would have to bow down to MS? If you're thinking of the shareholders, wouldn't you be concerned about what MS is going to do to Yahoo (destroy it)? Is it only a (small) gain in share price that matters? Long-term potential be damned?
Re:Battered Yahoo Admits It Overplayed Hand; Open To New Mic... by wanorris on Tuesday May 06, 2008 @12:07AM (#182171)
After years of underperforming, the shareholders saw a chance to take a stock that was selling for under $20 not that long ago and turn it into $33 or $34 a share. If you're scoring at home, that's a 65% or better increase in the value of their investment. And for options holders, there's a good chance that the price change is the difference between the options being underwater (i.e. worthless) and being worth quite a bit.

If that were your retirement fund or your stock options in your employer, wouldn't you want that money? And if you were a professional investor, wouldn't you be downright berzerk at all that money being thrown away?

Computer geeks like to go around badmouthing Microsoft all the time, but taking that attitude as a CEO or board member of a public company makes you unprofessional and irresponsible. To shareholders, Microsoft's money spends just like everyone else's.

Yahoo has underperformed for years. Sure, it has long-term potential. But investors have little reason to think the current management will realize this potential any better than the last couple of regimes. Meanwhile, as much as geeks love to hate Microsoft, they have decades of experience in producing enormous profits, and there's no particular reason to think that buying Yahoo will change that.

This isn't just short term vs. long term. This is realizing a return on investment vs. watching that return slip through your fingers. And investors are pissed.

Re:Battered Yahoo Admits It Overplayed Hand; Open To New Mic... by timr on Tuesday May 06, 2008 @07:46AM (#182368)
Here's the thing: if institutional investors truly believed that Yahoo was overplaying a weak hand, they could have sold their holdings at $28/share (or more).

These guys were gambling for a few bucks per share, just as much as Jerry Yang and the Yahoo board.

Re:Battered Yahoo Admits It Overplayed Hand; Open To New Mic... by pchristensen on Tuesday May 06, 2008 @02:51PM (#182697)
They couldn't liquidate hundreds of millions of shares at that price. The more they tried to sell off, the lower the price would go. In the acquisition, all of the shares would be bought at that price.
Re:Battered Yahoo Admits It Overplayed Hand; Open To New Mic... by timr on Tuesday May 06, 2008 @06:19PM (#182917)
Doesn't matter. If the institutional investors were so brilliantly prescient as to anticipate the failed negotiations, they could have easily profited from the knowledge. They didn't need to liquidate. Hell...simply making a public statement on the deal would have put immense pressure on Yahoo's board to sell. Where were they last week?

Point is, this stuff is largely crocodile tears. These guys weren't long because they thought Yahoo would be bought out, they were long because they saw value in the investment. Complaining now that Yahoo's negotiation strategy was somehow "irresponsible", is either massive hindsight bias, or part of some more complicated scheme....

Re:Battered Yahoo Admits It Overplayed Hand; Open To New Mic... by noelchurchill on Tuesday May 06, 2008 @12:17AM (#182178)
First of all, when/if Microsoft buys Yahoo, some big shareholders wont be shareholders anymore .. they'll be cashed out.

Microsoft is offering more per share than the current share price, benefiting shareholders.

A MicroHoo has better long term prospects of competing with Google, creating additional long term value for the shareholders.

Re:Battered Yahoo Admits It Overplayed Hand; Open To New Mic... by Xichekolas on Tuesday May 06, 2008 @10:44AM (#182482)
> A MicroHoo has better long term prospects of competing with Google

To compete with Google they need brilliant engineers and ideas. Merging isn't going to magically produce those. About the only advantage Microsoft offers Yahoo in this is access to their desktop and a huge pile of cash that allows Yahoo to chase crazy strategies with slim chances of huge payoff, assuming Yahoo has some ideas like that. Yahoo offers Microsoft eyeballs.

Re:Battered Yahoo Admits It Overplayed Hand; Open To New Mic... by wheels on Tuesday May 06, 2008 @11:07AM (#182505)
Could we stop already with the Google worshiping? Google's days as the break-away nerd company with more brains than bucks have been over for a while. A lot of Google's "brilliant ideas" were actually pioneered at Yahoo and then made their way over to Google (this goes for recent things too). Everybody's trying to be Google's baby, but Yahoo's not exactly been a slouch in internet innovation.
Re:Battered Yahoo Admits It Overplayed Hand; Open To New Mic... by Xichekolas on Tuesday May 06, 2008 @11:13AM (#182509)
I wasn't in any way trying to claim Google is the end-all-be-all of the Internet either. Sorry if the word 'brilliant' made it seem that way. I wish people would stop assuming that anything that doesn't outright slam Google implies that whoever wrote it is a fanboy. Google has a lead, and usually to overcome a lead by an established player in a market, you need to be brilliant. If you have been around here and sipped some of the startup kool-aid you would know that. I'm not even sure what "being Google's baby" means... but I'm definitely not trying to be one.

My point was that simply merging isn't going to magically create ideas and execution (good engineers). All it creates is a distraction, while the two sets of management elbow for position and a ton of employees flee.

So maybe MicroHoo doesn't need brilliant ideas and engineers, but it needs some of each, and merging isn't going to create any of either, and will most likely scare away quite a few of the great engineers that both companies already have.

Re:Battered Yahoo Admits It Overplayed Hand; Open To New Mic... by wheels on Tuesday May 06, 2008 @11:33AM (#182533)
Sorry for the tone; there is a lot of Google fanboi-ism on HN, so my reaction was as much to the general phenomenon as your post.

I think brilliant (well, clever is usually the word I would use, brilliance is much more rare) ideas are what make 4 guys in a garage able to take on a market leader, but when you've got a merger of companies with a combined market capitalization of over $300 billion, blunt force often does the trick. This is sumo wrestling, not fencing. :-)

And in the world of blunt force, the combined forces of the most profitable company in the technology market and the most popular site on the internet could pack a pretty hefty punch. I don't think that's a particularly good strategy for MS to pursue, but I wouldn't misunderestimate them.

Re:Battered Yahoo Admits It Overplayed Hand; Open To New Mic... by Xichekolas on Tuesday May 06, 2008 @01:14PM (#182612)
> This is sumo wrestling, not fencing.

Very good point.

I still think big companies can fence. Granted, Amazon's market cap is only like 1/10th of that ($32 billion), but it's AWS products are fairly innovative and leading their space at the moment. So big companies can innovate, they just seem slow and totally random about it.

I guess I'm just not seeing what there is to 'blunt force' in the market. You can't force people to buy your ad space. I guess if they could demonstrate clearly more eyeballs and higher CTR than adwords, advertisers would flock... is that what you envision?

Re:Battered Yahoo Admits It Overplayed Hand; Open To New Mic... by wheels on Tuesday May 06, 2008 @02:18PM (#182669)
Big companies can innovate, but the whole MS / Yahoo debacle seems to be about a clash of titans in entrenched spaces.

MS has a bigger warchest than Google and with the combined MS / Yahoo they'd have more eyes too. They could run that segment of their market at a loss for a while to try to steal some of Adwords' thunder. Think of MS's entrance into the game console or MP3 player markets. While, again, I don't think it's a great strategy to plow into entrenched markets like that, compared to creating new markets (a la your Amazon example), MS has certainly demonstrated a willingness to do so. In fact, I'd say that's almost they corporate modus operandi; almost their complete history has been bulldozing their way into markets using sheer brawn.

Re:Battered Yahoo Admits It Overplayed Hand; Open To New Mic... by astine on Monday May 05, 2008 @11:30PM (#182145)
Share holders buy and sell in the short term.

However, when Yahoo! stock gets bought by MS, it becomes MS stock. MS stock is worth more (I presume,) so the stock rises in value. Even if MS liquidates everything Yahoo! had, the stock remains MS stock. Stock is a share of the company. It isn't tied to any particular assets.

Re:Battered Yahoo Admits It Overplayed Hand; Open To New Mic... by pchristensen on Tuesday May 06, 2008 @02:53PM (#182698)
When stock is bought, it becomes money. If there's a stock swap, then it becomes MS stock.
Re:Battered Yahoo Admits It Overplayed Hand; Open To New Mic... by astine on Tuesday May 06, 2008 @02:59PM (#182709)
Yes, I rethought my statement this morning and slapped myself on the head, but by then the edit button had disappeared and didn't feel like replying to myself.