Re:Why Italy Could Be the Epicenter of the Next Financial Cr...
by toyg on Sunday October 14, 2018 @08:42AM
(#18212616)
> The Commission is the executive branch and the Parliament is legislative
Er, no. Commission and Council are both legislative and executive at the same time. The oversight organ is Parliament.
A lot of the of the ill-will against the EU setup comes from this non-traditional arrangement that betrays Montesquieu for the good of efficiency at scale: it's so hard and slow to write laws in national parliaments, that EU governments decided the model wouldn't work at continental level. You can look at the (in)efficiency of comparable bodies (US Congress and Indian parliament) to see the problem in action every day.
So multiple generations of EU politicians decided it would be easier to take hard decisions in a small room (Council), then leave it to the bureaucrats (Commission) to implement them. When the model was criticized for being undemocratic, they begrudgingly agreed to have a Parliament with veto powers. But democracy, once started, is a rolling boulder; so the role of EUParliament has grown with every election. The Commission cannot steamroll measures anymore, so EUP assumed a de-facto legislative role too. This is Good in historical terms and can only get better with time. Already the composition of the Commission has moved from a compromise brokered on purely-ethnic lines by national governments, to a body that also has to reflect the political inclinations of the sitting Parliament, lest they get rejected. Parliament will not rubber-stamp anymore.
The problem is that some elements of EU politics continue to be insulated from Parliament. Fiscal matters in particular, where states are completely unchecked, must be tied to Parliament in some way. Until that happens, demagogues will have an easy way to misdirect, talking of "Council" and "Troikas" as some unelected bodies when they are simple smokescreens for national governments to hide behind. It has to be corrected.
From a history-buff perspective, the current era is an exciting time: the continent is basically rewriting its constitutional asset in real-time. It's the sort of sea-change that happens once every 200 years; like a Vienna Congress or US Constitutional Convention, but spread over decades.
Er, no. Commission and Council are both legislative and executive at the same time. The oversight organ is Parliament.
A lot of the of the ill-will against the EU setup comes from this non-traditional arrangement that betrays Montesquieu for the good of efficiency at scale: it's so hard and slow to write laws in national parliaments, that EU governments decided the model wouldn't work at continental level. You can look at the (in)efficiency of comparable bodies (US Congress and Indian parliament) to see the problem in action every day.
So multiple generations of EU politicians decided it would be easier to take hard decisions in a small room (Council), then leave it to the bureaucrats (Commission) to implement them. When the model was criticized for being undemocratic, they begrudgingly agreed to have a Parliament with veto powers. But democracy, once started, is a rolling boulder; so the role of EUParliament has grown with every election. The Commission cannot steamroll measures anymore, so EUP assumed a de-facto legislative role too. This is Good in historical terms and can only get better with time. Already the composition of the Commission has moved from a compromise brokered on purely-ethnic lines by national governments, to a body that also has to reflect the political inclinations of the sitting Parliament, lest they get rejected. Parliament will not rubber-stamp anymore.
The problem is that some elements of EU politics continue to be insulated from Parliament. Fiscal matters in particular, where states are completely unchecked, must be tied to Parliament in some way. Until that happens, demagogues will have an easy way to misdirect, talking of "Council" and "Troikas" as some unelected bodies when they are simple smokescreens for national governments to hide behind. It has to be corrected.
From a history-buff perspective, the current era is an exciting time: the continent is basically rewriting its constitutional asset in real-time. It's the sort of sea-change that happens once every 200 years; like a Vienna Congress or US Constitutional Convention, but spread over decades.