In other words, bond ratings may not be the cause, but still be a cause.
Even the Enron case, which was a pretty clear case of fraud, took the government 5 years to build a case and win in court.
So, while all of those things you mention do indeed sound bad, they are incredibly difficult to prove in a criminal trial.
I can knowingly sell you a crappy car, and if you sign an agreement that you bought and accepted the good in its current state, that's that. Yes, I acted unethically, but I didn't defraud you.
Second, a successful prosecution requires proof beyond a reasonable doubt that a specific person performed each element of specific crimes. Defendants do not need to even present a defense--and in fact sometimes do not, relying entirely on poking holes in the government's case.
If I sell you a crappy asset (imagine a company almost going bankrupt) for $10m and you don't do proper due diligence on said asset, then you have no right of complaining afterwards. No one is going to do your homework.
If you know it is a crappy product, and don;t warn me, it is at the very least a SEC violation, punishable. Could also be viewed as fraud, and pursued as a crime.
They knew through sheer logic that one of these positions was by deduction not tenable.
But they went for it anyway, collecting commissions on both sides.
Now that's obviously not a terribly smart idea. But there's simply no way to blame any single individual when none of them had the power to the system by themselves. I mean: quite obviously the companies being rated would have loved for others to bear the costs for it.
b) the senior executives at institutions like bear stearns who signed off on creating the mortgage backed securities and their known composition of shit mortgages.
c) the senior executives at the rating agencies who knowingly rated shit bonds as AAA.
d) senior executives at institutions like Countrywide which pumped the shit mortgages into the market.