News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Trump Just Signed a Law That Changes Life Aboard Airlines by rayiner on Friday October 12, 2018 @07:51PM (#18205508)
> what a flight should include (one checked, 1 person+1 carryon).

This basically forces me (who never checks anything) to subsidize your (I assume) traveling habits.

Re:Trump Just Signed a Law That Changes Life Aboard Airlines by zbentley on Friday October 12, 2018 @08:14PM (#18205596)
What is wrong with that?

There are numerous entirely private systems that require such subsidy; are you claiming that any amount of subsidy for others' habits is objectionable (i.e. the libertarian hardline)? Or are you making some other point?

Re:Trump Just Signed a Law That Changes Life Aboard Airlines by brandonmenc on Friday October 12, 2018 @08:40PM (#18205705)
Ticket prices are lower now than ever.

Poorer people can opt out of checking luggage in order to make that visit to a dying relative possible.

Everyone here forgets what it was like when a domestic flight cost the equivalent of $600 - which is out of reach for a lot of people.

Charging for luggage and dining separate from the ticket makes that possible, in part.

Re:Trump Just Signed a Law That Changes Life Aboard Airlines by monksy on Friday October 12, 2018 @09:57PM (#18205956)
Except now it'll be $540 while fuel is still low. It's going to go up even higher when fuel goes up.
Re:Trump Just Signed a Law That Changes Life Aboard Airlines by rayiner on Friday October 12, 2018 @10:41PM (#18206092)
I'm happy to subsidize, you know, low-income moms who need nutrition benefits. Why the heck should I subsidize people who pack too much on domestic trips?
Re:Trump Just Signed a Law That Changes Life Aboard Airlines by wtallis on Saturday October 13, 2018 @12:15AM (#18206400)
What's your threshold for packing "too much"? Do you believe that everybody should be able to get by with an under-seat bag? Or are you pretending that the overhead bins are large enough for everyone to bring a standard piece of carry-on luggage?

Either way, it's still possible to check smaller pieces of luggage, and if most passengers could do that economically then loading and unloading the plane would be a lot quicker, saving the airlines non-trivial costs.

Re:Trump Just Signed a Law That Changes Life Aboard Airlines by monksy on Friday October 12, 2018 @08:07PM (#18205567)
Without fees, the airline is minimizing the cost and you're cost averaging. With the fee-based structure, it's really a massive cost increase and a service/quality decrease.

From what you said it's abit like saying that you don't want to subsidize the police via your taxes because you never use them.

Re:Trump Just Signed a Law That Changes Life Aboard Airlines by tomp on Saturday October 13, 2018 @05:51AM (#18207248)
There are freerider benefits of having police. There’s no freerider benefits of other people packing more.
Re:Trump Just Signed a Law That Changes Life Aboard Airlines by rayiner on Friday October 12, 2018 @10:46PM (#18206109)
Spirit airlines makes like 10% profit margin. Forcing them to absorb baggage fees isn't going to come out of their margins, it's going to come out of increases in base fare.

As to subsidies: you usually can't control whether you need the police or not. You generally can control how much you pack. My wife and I didn't even pack a check-in on when we took the kid to Disney World recently. Why should I pay more for people who have to have … whatever the hell it is that people pack in a checked bag for a domestic flight.