News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Berea College Makes Tuition Free with its Endowment by gregw2 on Friday October 12, 2018 @03:59PM (#18204274)
Beware friendly Berea-- of the temptation to change your tuition free-stance, even a little bit. It's a slippery slope.

Rice University was founded in 1912 with an endowment and grants and the stipulation in its very charter saying "no tuition", but then the administrators moved to change the charter (to eliminate the racist "white" requirement) and as part of that also, guess what, moved to start charging (1965) rather than depending on the endowment.

The tuition has grown steadily since, from 0 to a third the price of comparable private schools in the 90s (and comparable price to public universities) to now be a pretty full-freight $50k/year.

This, combined with the steadily increasing tuition across all universities -- (inflation eased in 1982 but colleges kept increasing rates discovering the market would allow them to charge more) -- has cynically angered me for some time.

Unlike a business, the tax-sheltered endowments fuel a bit more cynicism than just a raw price increase. There was a joke at Princeton back in the 90s that if the board of directors ever allowed the university to spend down the endowment, they could fund ever-increasing tuition for all students for the next thousand years. Is perpetuity truly needed/healthy?

An education is supposed to free a person, not put them in bondage/slavery.

An endowment should free and empower the students (and thus our civilization) as they start their lives, not the administrators and faculty and institution.

Beware, you educators and administrators who put chains on your students to feather your nest and attempt to increase your prestige!

Beware you administrators who create unnecessary buildings with dozens of spaces empty 90% of the time all to woo professors or create your own mini-legacy. And then claim the university is meeting glowing "sustainability" and energy efficiency objectives! (You may get to stay in your office but the degree of walking for students ever-increases and now shuttles are needed!)

Beware you ranking agencies who weight how much a university spends per student as a factor in how good the university is!

Beware you congresspeople who make it easier for universities to charge more by creating huge student loan programs that allow students to go into great debt and subtly mis-direct their ambitions and outcomes towards those which allow them to service their debt!

OK, rant out. Thanks for passing along the article. There has been some progress at the above named institutions to provide tuition for lower-income families. I don't consider it adequate to address all my points.

Re:How Berea College Makes Tuition Free with its Endowment by darkerside on Friday October 12, 2018 @04:29PM (#18204475)
I empathize with your viewpoint, but this may not be the place for rage. Berea is doing things right, even from your perspective. Shouldn't we applaud that instead of taking this opportunity to cast stones?
Re:How Berea College Makes Tuition Free with its Endowment by gregw2 on Saturday October 13, 2018 @08:13AM (#18207593)
I applaud Berea. Just want them not to take it for granted having witnessed other schools slide off the path they're on.
Re:How Berea College Makes Tuition Free with its Endowment by DoreenMichele on Friday October 12, 2018 @09:25PM (#18205861)
I will briefly note that getting a world class education completely for free is an extreme form of privilege that few people can hope for. There can be a downside to that.

I once saw a question on a very toxic forum by some self proclaimed idealist with a scholarship who was extremely critical of their classmates and their obsession with trying to find a well paid job after graduation. It seemed lost on this jerk that most of their classmates likely were saddled with crushing student debt and would need well paid jobs to service their student loans.

I don't know what the solution is. I do know that when people get something completely for free, they typically undervalue it and frequently don't really appreciate it, among other things.

Re:How Berea College Makes Tuition Free with its Endowment by olingern on Sunday October 14, 2018 @02:31AM (#18211651)
To get into Berea your family has to meet financial requirements[1]. Translated: "you're poor enough." So, the common background of everyone on campus is pretty humble.

There will be jerks anywhere-- that's a given. But, I can assure you that most of all graduates who come from Berea are very grateful to the institution especially given the insane rate at which tuition continues to increase.

Since it's a liberal arts program, writing and reasoning are a core part of the curriculum. I would say by virtue of going through the program, you're able to better appreciate it at the end. I think learning about the world at an age when your views are malleable is more meaningful than learning about compilers.

1- https://www.berea.edu/admissions/financial-requirement/

Re:How Berea College Makes Tuition Free with its Endowment by gregw2 on Saturday October 13, 2018 @08:23AM (#18207614)
I hear you.

The culturally-encouraged pseudo-slavery of debt really bothers me.

Re:How Berea College Makes Tuition Free with its Endowment by DoreenMichele on Saturday October 13, 2018 @12:58PM (#18208892)
Yes, that really bothers me too. Ideally, I would like to see a situation where it is possible to have an entry level job, cheap rental and apply for standard federal financial aid and make it work with some reasonable degree of effort at a fairly high percentage of schools.

One of my concerns with free tuition at elite universities is that it is likely to become one more way that "them that has, gets." My suspicion is that the vast majority of slots will still go to kids from wealthy families, though ability to pay is no longer one of the ways poor people get excluded. There are lots of ways to exclude poor people without using their income per se as a means to exclude them.

If the most elite colleges have free tuition and you see rich kids getting a free ride because of it, then the gulf between rich and poor only grows. It won't shrink.

That's very problematic, for a long list of reasons.

One issue is that we should be looking to make education available to those with interest and ability in a particular area. We should be developing policies with an eye towards furthering human and societal development. Education that is too much about credentialing can turn into justification for "welfare for the rich." You get the job because you have the credentials. You got the credentials because of who your dad was, not because you are actually interested or talented. It makes you sure you remain comfortably upper class, never mind that you are essentially a leech on society.

There are two ways to be rich:

1. Add enough value that everyone is better off, including you.

2. Extract value from the world and society such that you are very much better off, but it is questionable if anyone else is. Your employees have terrible lives. The environment is being destroyed. Etc. But, hey, your bank account remains fat and that's all that matters.

The world needs to perpetually guard against that second thing. And we struggle with it.

Re:How Berea College Makes Tuition Free with its Endowment by ChrisLomont on Friday October 12, 2018 @08:30PM (#18205669)
> There was a joke at Princeton back in the 90s that if the board of directors ever allowed the university to spend down the endowment, they could fund ever-increasing tuition for all students for the next thousand years.

Back of envelope: Princeton endowment ~22B. Enrollment ~8200. Current tuition ~$45K/yr. 22 * 10^9/(8200 * 45000) = 59.6.

So in ~60 years, without even adding in inflation or the "ever-increasing tuition" or allowing more students as population increases, they'd empty the endowment.

Re:How Berea College Makes Tuition Free with its Endowment by nshelly on Friday October 12, 2018 @08:41PM (#18205710)
Princeton's current 2018 size is $25.9B. In 2001 it was $8.4B, so a annual growth rate of over 6% per year.

So Princeton would have to spend 1.6% of their endowment every year to offer free tuition to their students. Assuming their rate of return on the endowment (including alumni contributions) can grow faster than the cost of tuition growth, they can provide free tuition for their students indefinitely.

Re:How Berea College Makes Tuition Free with its Endowment by ChrisLomont on Sunday October 14, 2018 @12:25PM (#18213634)
Princeton tuition was 26K in 2001. It is now 45K. That's 3% growth in tuition, cutting into your estimate.

The current growth is already being spent to fund the university to the tune of ~4-6% [1].

So, if you take that source away, tuition would likely have to pick up the slack.

Care to rerun your numbers adding this all in?

[1] https://www.princeton.edu/news/2013/10/18/princeton-endowmen...

Re:How Berea College Makes Tuition Free with its Endowment by ckuhl on Friday October 12, 2018 @08:40PM (#18205703)
That’s assuming the rest of the endowment isn’t reinvested. You’d need less than a 2% annual return on that $22B to fund the tuition in perpetuity.
Re:How Berea College Makes Tuition Free with its Endowment by ChrisLomont on Sunday October 14, 2018 @12:26PM (#18213639)
Princeton tuition was 26K in 2001. It is now 45K. That's 3% growth in tuition, cutting into your estimate.

The current endowment growth is already being spent to fund the university to the tune of ~4-6% [1].

So, if you take that source away, tuition would likely have to pick up the slack.

Care to rerun your numbers adding this all in?

[1] https://www.princeton.edu/news/2013/10/18/princeton-endowmen...