Re:Mathematics as thought
by astroalex on Friday October 12, 2018 @03:18PM
(#18203959)
Good points.
> Likewise, if you get a royal flush in a hand of poker, you probably won't get as good a hand next time.
I understand what you mean, but I think that most people who haven't taken a probability class would misinterpret this. A sentence of the form "if [this] then [that]" is usually meant to express dependence. Don't you think that most people would interpret your sentence as: "Because I got a royal flush this time, I probably won't get one next time."?
I think the average pop-sci article reader will get confused by this.
Re:Mathematics as thought
by leetcrew on Friday October 12, 2018 @04:47PM
(#18204602)
it's really hard to map subtle statements about probability to natural English sentences. pretty much any non-awkward formulation of that sentence is going to admit misinterpretations.
> Likewise, if you get a royal flush in a hand of poker, you probably won't get as good a hand next time.
I understand what you mean, but I think that most people who haven't taken a probability class would misinterpret this. A sentence of the form "if [this] then [that]" is usually meant to express dependence. Don't you think that most people would interpret your sentence as: "Because I got a royal flush this time, I probably won't get one next time."?
I think the average pop-sci article reader will get confused by this.