Re:Millions of workers believe they are bound by non-binding...
by gpm on Thursday October 11, 2018 @03:24PM
(#18196297)
I find it strange that having people sign contracts you know (or should know) are invalid isn't considered fraud. It seems to me that this is lying for monetary gain at the expense of the other party and should result in both civil damages and criminal charges in a sane legal system.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Millions of workers believe they are bound by non-binding...
by jessriedel on Thursday October 11, 2018 @03:43PM
(#18196453)
Unenforceable and invalid are not the same thing.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unenforceable
More generally, contracts can have moral weight (by the lights of the signing parties) even if the state declines to enforce it in court.
Re:Millions of workers believe they are bound by non-binding...
by marcosdumay on Thursday October 11, 2018 @06:00PM
(#18197365)
That moral weight is part of the problem. If the State did go through the bother of taking an style of clause apart, pointing into it and saying "look, you can't do this", it's because there is a moral problem with that style.
People pushing unenforceable contracts are exerting some immoral power into other people, expecting them to comply due to those others' morality.
Re:Millions of workers believe they are bound by non-binding...
by jessriedel on Thursday October 11, 2018 @06:34PM
(#18197554)
> If the State did go through the bother of taking an style of clause apart, pointing into it and saying "look, you can't do this", it's because there is a moral problem with that style.
It says something about the moral assessments of the people forming the political system (plus something about non-moral political factors), but that doesn't mean that the parties signing the contract don't find the clause moral by their own lights. (And likewise, if you're a moral objectivist, the clause can continue to be moral even as the political system is making a moral mistake.)