Personally, I feel the same way. But it's illogical. What data do you have that you're good at ferreting the genuine from the not?
That actually reminded me of a really cool poscast episode I listened to this week:
https://www.gimletmedia.com/reply-all/long-distance
(A guy trying to get to the bottom of an indian call-center scam, leading to all sorts of pleasant interactions along the way)
https://www.gimletmedia.com/reply-all/103-long-distance-part...
I think that‘s what most people do. I‘m actually waiting for me to be „completely duped“ one time and deliberately exposing myself to this risk. However, my experience so far has lead me to believe: Most people are really nice and the few that aren‘t shouldn‘t really be tainting your interactions with others that you just happen to not know yet.
If my mum knew about this she'd probably think I'm crazy, being afraid of someone running off with her stuff. But in the end I think "trust-by-default" is a good way of going about life and meeting new people. Also, there's still gut-feeling. Maybe I'm an outlier there but I'm pretty quick in determining if someone is being sincere or just sweet-talking me to get what he/she wants.