Re:Leaked Google briefing, admitting a “shift towards censor...
by noobermin on Wednesday October 10, 2018 @12:18AM
(#18181933)
I don't know where you got "left leaning" from unless you're bending over backwards to be fair, they are if anything centrists which makes sense since they're Google. For heaven's sake, the slide about conversations of free speech, I see establishment centrist media pieces on the same plot as Breitbart and WorldNetDaily. An equivalent would be listing the Young Turks or alternet.
Re:Leaked Google briefing, admitting a “shift towards censor...
by twmb on Wednesday October 10, 2018 @12:24AM
(#18181953)
I think it is fair, but I can imagine a scenario where a person reads a line and thinks "this is obviously leftist".
Personally, I think company's have been bending over backwards to prove they aren't biasing against the right.
Re:Leaked Google briefing, admitting a “shift towards censor...
by tropo on Wednesday October 10, 2018 @12:37AM
(#18181992)
On the two pages titled "But recent global events have undermined this utopian narrative" there are a total of 8 events depicted. The viewer is expected to think that the events are problems. About 4 or 5 of the events would be considered good by many on the right, but bad by the left. The remaining events are just gross, weird, and otherwise unrelated to the US political spectrum.
Re:Leaked Google briefing, admitting a “shift towards censor...
by shittyadmin on Wednesday October 10, 2018 @12:14AM
(#18181909)
Yeah, honestly I don't think Breitbart and similar can really play this as negative for Google when it acknowledges many actions have been taken even against right wingers unfairly and encourages "Don't take sides" as a top point.
The biggest thing to complain about would probably be the title... they couldn't have picked a worse title.
Re:Leaked Google briefing, admitting a “shift towards censor...
by WillPostForFood on Wednesday October 10, 2018 @01:50AM
(#18182326)
The negative for Google isn't what the briefing suggests, it is that it documents bias, it notes the impossible tension between the US and European values, and says that Google has been leaning away from US values. I think that's what Breitbart would be primarily reacting to.
Re:Leaked Google briefing, admitting a “shift towards censor...
by adventured on Wednesday October 10, 2018 @12:34AM
(#18181981)
There's a larger question that Breitbart is raising: should we tolerate Google - or any company - as a monopolist with censorship power over information distribution. In this case, they're an extraordinarily powerful, expansive monopolist at that. Who decides the degree to which they censor, who gets censored, what information gets censored, etc. Google isn't just a company policing its own platform. Imagine Microsoft aggressively censoring what people could browse, upload to the Internet or write on its operating system in ~2001 (or any time during peak Windows monopoly): it'd be an obvious monopoly abuse, harm to consumers, and as an extension of that monopoly position a form of censorship. Google, through the leverage of its multiple monopolies (search, YouTube, Android), is pushing toward that sort of behavior.
Re:Leaked Google briefing, admitting a “shift towards censor...
by shittyadmin on Wednesday October 10, 2018 @12:56AM
(#18182059)
I was going to say that they're not really doing it on Android, but then I remembered that both Apple and Google banned the free speech absolutist social network Gab's official app.
At least on Android you can still install it without Google's consent if you so choose. Overall though what you're saying still has more validity to it than I'd like to admit.
As for the why:
As for the conclusions: Most of the document is non-controversial. There are places where it can be seen as obviously left leaning, but there are also places where it acknowledges that sometimes the right has been treated worse: