News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by CPLX on Monday October 08, 2018 @01:43PM (#18169550)
The use of the word "sunset" as a verb in posts like this is fucking infuriating. Yes, software types know what it means, but this is a consumer product with tens of millions of users, who have no familiarity with that term.

It's a weasel word. The way to say this is in plain English. We're closing, shutting down, turning off, discontinuing, or something.

Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by zdragnar on Monday October 08, 2018 @01:51PM (#18169635)
What? Sunsetting something is used outside of software. Hell, it's even used to describe temporary laws ("sunset law"). It's also used for brands and business policies.

And, sure, it might not make the top list of 1000 words you might hear on the street on any given day, but it's also very easy to search for. That doesn't make it a weasel word.

Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by huebomont on Monday October 08, 2018 @01:55PM (#18169684)
It's absolutely a weasel word, because there are plenty of common and clear ways to say this. The only reason it exists is so companies don't have to use words that connote a lack of success.
Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by drewfrank on Monday October 08, 2018 @03:04PM (#18170308)
I think it exists because it's a concise way to communicate "this is ending, and will end in a predetermined amount of time, but it has not yet ended" in the same manner that sunset indicates that a day is ending but has not ended yet.
Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by CPLX on Monday October 08, 2018 @04:40PM (#18171105)
I think this reply actually captures one of the problems with the term. It's super passive.

I realize this usage is becoming an official usage, but the original meaning was something that would end by design and automatically unless it was renewed. Like a law had a sunset provision if it already had an ending named at the time it was created. So the ending is built into the original plan from the beginning, it's bound to happen unless something changes.

Like... a sunset.

It's not something passive that's happened at Google though. They're saying we are going to close a service that is open, and has been expected to stay open indefinitely. It's not a thing that is just kind of happening, it's a decision that was just made and is being newly announced.

Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by lucb1e on Monday October 08, 2018 @03:24PM (#18170492)
I'm a non-native speaker and sunsetting is not clear to me. I guessed what it means because I know Google and how popular Google+ is (in relative terms, I'm sure there's still hundreds of thousands of people who will lose contacts over this), but if someone had said Cloudflare is sunsetting, I'd just not have known what it meant.

And even knowing what it means, as I do now, I wouldn't say that sunsetting is any clearer in communicating that it's "going to" end than "shutting down" or "stopping" Google+. It's not as if the proposal said "ended" or "shut down" Google+, the "are" in something like "We're shutting down Google+" signals continuation to me.

Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by ncocacola on Monday October 08, 2018 @03:40PM (#18170644)
There you have it, you've learned a new word!
Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by wetpaws on Monday October 08, 2018 @04:30PM (#18171019)
"Slaughter" would be a much better word and much closer to truth, imo.
Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by noja on Monday October 08, 2018 @02:07PM (#18169786)
The whole post is a weasel word: they exposed data on hundreds of thousands of users THEN CHOSE NOT TO DECLARE THAT. Come on Google.
Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by jkaplowitz on Monday October 08, 2018 @01:52PM (#18169639)
This post is on the technology section of Google's blog and makes many technical comments about APIs and permissions.

It is therefore presumably not the primary consumer-facing announcement of the shutdown.

Hopefully they will use one of the terms you noted, or something similar, for that announcement.

Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by 8ytecoder on Monday October 08, 2018 @01:53PM (#18169654)
That's not true. Sunset years - to mean "a period of decline, especially the last years of a person's life" - is pretty well known. Irrespective of my background that's the first thought that pop into my head.
Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by huebomont on Monday October 08, 2018 @01:56PM (#18169688)
That's an adjective. "Sunsetting" as a verb is an obnoxious use of language to avoid saying "we failed and are closing"
Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by myth_buster on Monday October 08, 2018 @03:56PM (#18170780)
FWIW, the action from finding 1 reads

> Action 1: We are _shutting down_ Google+ for consumers.

Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by _emacsomancer_ on Monday October 08, 2018 @05:32PM (#18171508)
I find "consumer Google+" much more confusing than "sunset(ting)".
Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by arbitrage on Monday October 08, 2018 @04:28PM (#18171003)
> fucking

> software types

> weasel word

Pull the plank from your own eye first.

Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by jasonlotito on Monday October 08, 2018 @01:59PM (#18169720)
From the post, literally in bold, and listed as the first action.

"We are shutting down Google+ for consumers."

> this is fucking infuriating

Comments like yours are much worse.