News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Teaching CS in the schools by bluGill on Monday October 08, 2018 @11:46AM (#18168489)
Why?

Obviously we need some students to become programmers, and we should start them early, but do we need all students? The student who wants to be a doctor should learn to type and then move on to more science/biology classes. The student who isn't sure what they want to do with their life (this is most, even though they all have done a "what I want to be when I grow up paper") needs to good general background. going deep into math, science, and reading/writing (ie the 3 Rs) will get them much father than specialized education in computers - they can figure out what they need to know a lot better than someone with a deep knowledge of CS can figure out something else.

Computers are tools. They are useful when you know some other domain well and then use the computer to take care of some work for you.

Re:Teaching CS in the schools by ergothus on Monday October 08, 2018 @12:04PM (#18168616)
> Obviously we need some students to become programmers, and we should start them early, but do we need all students?

I've always viewed the current use of programmers to be temporary - in the future, most people will so a little programming, but much of their day will be in their specialty.

Because most everyone would benefit from some programming, but not enough to justify pairing them with one or neglecting their other duties entirely.

Today we are crippled by a lack of coders. Take most anyones jobs (who isnt a coder) and you are likely to find ways a program or two would help - but not enough to justify using one of the too-rare coders. Once they can code a bit themselves, they can quickly address that problem.

Most people interface with a computer during their jobs, even many physical-labor based tasks. It's a small step to ask them to code a bit.

The rest of us that code 100% will be making tools and analytics, not doing a job that could easily be replaced if enough people knew excel.

Re:Teaching CS in the schools by gowld on Monday October 08, 2018 @11:58AM (#18168582)
Why teach Chemistry, Literature, Music, Physics, or History?

Why is "science" one of "the 3Rs", but computer science is not?

Re:Teaching CS in the schools by JoeAltmaier on Monday October 08, 2018 @12:02PM (#18168605)
Honestly, they stay the same long enough to teach something lasting. Teach java? Wait, no! Now its JavaScript. No! Clojure or Haskell or whatnot.
Re:Teaching CS in the schools by bluGill on Monday October 08, 2018 @01:59PM (#18169725)
Because science is basic principals that you can build many other things on. Thus not knowing some science is limiting.