Re:Words Matter – Moving Beyond “Meritocracy”
by furgooswft13 on Monday October 08, 2018 @10:35AM
(#18167805)
"Meritocracy" is only tarnished by the very same people writing blogs like this. Don't be surprised if you spend years trashing a house then suddenly realize you don't want to live there anymore. Plenty of people will continue to use the word and try to live up to it's concept because they did not buy the FUD heaped on it (by the very people who now conveniently want to abandon it) in the first place.
Re:Words Matter – Moving Beyond “Meritocracy”
by cirgue on Monday October 08, 2018 @10:25AM
(#18167705)
> "Sometimes good words and good aspirations get tarnished with history, and need to be set aside"
Every word, every ideal, and every good intention becomes tarnished by history. Humanity is not a perfect phenomenon: it is deeply imperfect. There is no way to have progress if our moral view of the world is purely associative.
Re:Words Matter – Moving Beyond “Meritocracy”
by raxxorrax on Monday October 08, 2018 @10:20AM
(#18167658)
> Like "traditional American values" and "celebration of European culture"
Or diversity and inclusiveness.
Re:Words Matter – Moving Beyond “Meritocracy”
by pgeorgi on Monday October 08, 2018 @10:41AM
(#18167873)
Step 1: Point out how horrible "meritocracy" is
Step 2: Bemoan that you need a new word for what meritocracy used to mean
Step 3: ??? (my guess is: rinse and repeat)
Re:Words Matter – Moving Beyond “Meritocracy”
by CWuestefeld on Monday October 08, 2018 @10:19AM
(#18167648)
Well, the OP mentions it. But you haven't actually provided any rebuttal to my analogy with terminology for other missed goals. I think they're pretty good examples of words that are "historically tarnished" in similar ways.
Re:Words Matter – Moving Beyond “Meritocracy”
by cheeseomlit on Monday October 08, 2018 @10:21AM
(#18167665)
We're not allowed to talk about celebrating European culture anymore?
Re:Words Matter – Moving Beyond “Meritocracy”
by danharaj on Monday October 08, 2018 @10:24AM
(#18167699)
What the hell is European culture? German culture, Italian culture, Romanian culture, sure. But...?
Re:Words Matter – Moving Beyond “Meritocracy”
by cheeseomlit on Monday October 08, 2018 @10:28AM
(#18167734)
You just said what it is? I mean, what is Hispanic culture if not Mexican/Spanish/Venezuelan/etc., what the hell is Asian culture if not Chinese/Japanese/Korean/etc.
Re:Words Matter – Moving Beyond “Meritocracy”
by danharaj on Monday October 08, 2018 @10:37AM
(#18167840)
I don't think I've ever heard anyone say "celebrate Asian culture". Precisely because it's a barely meaningful agglomeration. Now if we examine the context in which "European culture" is celebrated... hm, yes I see.
Re:Words Matter – Moving Beyond “Meritocracy”
by true_religion on Monday October 08, 2018 @11:13AM
(#18168169)
I have heard it. There are just generic Asian American society functions, which celebrate the melting pot of everyone who isn't strictly first generation and has multiple ethnic backgrounds.
Re:Words Matter – Moving Beyond “Meritocracy”
by AstralStorm on Monday October 08, 2018 @01:43PM
(#18169553)
That would be Asian American culture then, except Americans tend to not notice that their culture is not everywhere and needs qualification.
[dead]
Re:Words Matter – Moving Beyond “Meritocracy”
by cheeseomlit on Monday October 08, 2018 @11:22AM
(#18168251)
I'm aware and I don't care. I'm a product of those cultures and I'm happy to celebrate them- and I certainly won't allow others to dictate my lexicon based on association with groups they don't like
Re:Words Matter – Moving Beyond “Meritocracy”
by notacoward on Monday October 08, 2018 @12:06PM
(#18168639)
Then I'm sure you wouldn't have a problem with whatever name they choose to call you based on your skin color etc., right? Because it's their lexicon, it's not for you to decide. Or maybe being able to say others must accept your choice of words is an assertion of privilege.
Re:Words Matter – Moving Beyond “Meritocracy”
by java_script on Monday October 08, 2018 @11:26AM
(#18168281)
Ok fair. Then would they be wrong to associate you with those groups? Ie in the debates those ‘groups’ tend to wage, do you fall on their side?
Re:Words Matter – Moving Beyond “Meritocracy”
by cheeseomlit on Monday October 08, 2018 @11:45AM
(#18168475)
Depends on the issue and the group. If you're making the argument that those who have no issue with the phrase 'celebrating European culture' tend to be more conservative then I'd agree
"Sometimes good words and good aspirations get tarnished with history, and need to be set aside"
...and...
"Sadly, “meritocracy” is not that word. Maybe it once was, or could have been. But not today."
Like it or not, words have more than etymological meaning. They also have historical and cultural meaning, that might be sharply at odds with their etymology, and that precludes their use even in situations where they're technically accurate. "Meritocracy" has become such a word. Like "traditional American values" and "celebration of European culture" as synonyms for racism, "meritocracy" has become a rallying cry for opposition to diversity, inclusion, and egalitarianism. All as the person who originally coined the word meant it, BTW. We can coin new words that are just as etymologically valid without the cultural baggage.