That is very different from asking Apple to promote apps - just host them, police malicious apps, and take a small cut of profits for the service. Admittedly, that's a bit different from a package manager, but it's clear, consistent, and really the best option for Mac UX.
Reasonable people can argue about the downsides of the iOS app stores, but I don't see how reasonable people could think that Apple should give an inch on it's Apple-branded OS X app store. The platform already has extremely good unrestricted third party development support.
They also reduce the quality of third-party software, as even blessed software developers will still have to put time into planning for pushing their own updates should they fail to win Apple's blessing.
In reality, the OS X app store is nothing more than a turbocharged version of Apple's own OS X software directory site. If you don't want to bend your app to qualify for it, just set up your own site. It's not reasonable to say Apple has to promote arbitrary applications.