News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:US to Allow Cars Without Steering Wheels by jaxtellerSoA on Friday October 05, 2018 @02:31PM (#18150529)
I'll keep my gasoline car with a steering wheel....thanks.
Re:US to Allow Cars Without Steering Wheels by excalibur on Friday October 05, 2018 @03:18PM (#18150954)
I'm not married to the gasoline, but I don't think I'll ever be comfortable in a car that can't be driven manually.
Re:US to Allow Cars Without Steering Wheels by krapp on Friday October 05, 2018 @08:00PM (#18152695)
Good luck keeping it once manually driven cars are declared a public safety hazard and driving them is illegal.
Re:US to Allow Cars Without Steering Wheels by longerthoughts on Friday October 05, 2018 @08:15PM (#18152741)
Is this likely to happen in our lifetime? As far as I know it's reasonable from a technology perspective, but I'm imagining this being a profoundly divisive political issue where politicians stall meaningful legislation for decades in the name of liberty (at least in the US). I'm basically imagining a watered down version of the debate over firearm ownership without the obstacle of a constitutional amendment. Maybe I'm projecting present circumstances onto the future a bit too much.
Re:US to Allow Cars Without Steering Wheels by krapp on Friday October 05, 2018 @08:31PM (#18152794)
I can imagine it possibly happening on a small scale limited to urban areas in the near future, possibly as an attempt to manage congestion, and I can see trucking being automated (at least on highways with some human intervention) and taxis, but I don't see the public accepting a total transition until the technology has proven trustworthy and seems so obviously more safe than the alternative.

That could happen, but if it did, it would probably require a generational shift in public perspective.

Re:US to Allow Cars Without Steering Wheels by longerthoughts on Friday October 05, 2018 @08:45PM (#18152835)
> I don't see the public accepting a total transition until the technology has proven trustworthy and seems so obviously more safe than the alternative.

This would definitely be the minimum requirement, but it would be consistent with history (cigarettes, firearms, climate change, etc.) for people to deny any safety advantages or simply not be persuaded by them long after research suggests safety benefits.

Re:US to Allow Cars Without Steering Wheels by jaxtellerSoA on Monday October 08, 2018 @04:11PM (#18170878)
There is no amount of "safety" that would make automated driverless pods an acceptable alternative to manually driven vehicles.
Re:US to Allow Cars Without Steering Wheels by longerthoughts on Monday October 08, 2018 @06:25PM (#18171852)
Acceptable in what regard? Are you arguing that they can never be safer or just that nothing could compel you to convert personally?
Re:US to Allow Cars Without Steering Wheels by userbinator on Friday October 05, 2018 @08:22PM (#18152768)
I imagine there will be plenty of resistance to that.

The lawmakers would have to ban motorcycles first.

What was that old saying again... "Those who give up freedom for security deserve neither."

Re:US to Allow Cars Without Steering Wheels by skinnymuch on Sunday October 07, 2018 @06:56AM (#18159970)
I don’t think that quote works so well with the insane amount of car deaths we have. Cars also being something created by us in the last 150 years. Not some universal things.
Re:US to Allow Cars Without Steering Wheels by jaxtellerSoA on Monday October 08, 2018 @04:09PM (#18170871)
I wouldn't give up manually driven cars for anything. You can rip the keys out of my cold dead hands.
Re:US to Allow Cars Without Steering Wheels by JoeAltmaier on Monday October 08, 2018 @04:11PM (#18170881)
If most of the cars on the road are auto-drive, that might be exactly what happens. Imagine trying to negotiate crossing a busy highway when all the other cars know what they're each doing, and you're invisible to them. It'll be 'playing chicken' all day long.
Re:US to Allow Cars Without Steering Wheels by jaxtellerSoA on Monday October 08, 2018 @04:17PM (#18170917)
> you're invisible to them.

If that's the case then self-driving cars will never take off. What are they only aware of other self-driving cars? How about children? Or a tree that fell in the road? They would have to be aware of any object.

Re:US to Allow Cars Without Steering Wheels by marter on Friday October 05, 2018 @02:35PM (#18150575)
Not for long
Re:US to Allow Cars Without Steering Wheels by Sohcahtoa82 on Friday October 05, 2018 @03:23PM (#18150985)
Longer than you think.

A quick Google search for average car age hints that it's nearly 12 years [0]. Even if everyone buying a new car bought an EV, we're probably 12 years away from 50% of the cars on the road being EVs. And since the age trend is actually increasing, we're probably looking at 13-15 years in actuality. And again, that assumes 100% of new vehicles purchased are EV, which definitely isn't the case.

This doesn't even begin to look at self-driving. We're still years away from reliable level 4 automation.

[0] https://www.cnbc.com/2017/05/28/car-owners-are-holding-their...

Re:US to Allow Cars Without Steering Wheels by coldtea on Friday October 05, 2018 @02:41PM (#18150634)
You'd be surprised. Self driving cars will have their AI-winter time soon (not to imply that they hit the spotlight yet)
Re:US to Allow Cars Without Steering Wheels by thrmsforbfast on Friday October 05, 2018 @03:06PM (#18150845)
> Self driving cars will have their AI-winter time soon

I don't see this happening any time soon. There might be a contraction in highly speculative investments (i.e., VC cash) aimed at autonomous driving systems. However, even if tech never gets beyond level 2, this will still be a high-growth and high-wage field for the next couple of decades as automobile manufacturers and their tier one suppliers incorporate existing ADAS across the lineup.

And that's to say nothing of the many limited domains where level 4 is definitely doable, including closed-environment mining and manufacturing sites. As well as adjacent industries (e.g., maritime) where even levels 1 and 2 could help a lot.

Self-driving is a scorching hot fireball right now. It might cool down as people realize that level 4-5 is not happening any time soon, but a prolonged winter is hard to believe.

Re:US to Allow Cars Without Steering Wheels by coldtea on Saturday October 06, 2018 @05:51AM (#18154339)
>And that's to say nothing of the many limited domains where level 4 is definitely doable, including closed-environment mining and manufacturing sites. As well as adjacent industries (e.g., maritime) where even levels 1 and 2 could help a lot.

Yeah, I have no doubt about special purpose level 4 in limited environments. My comment was about seeing general purpose 4 and 5.

Re:US to Allow Cars Without Steering Wheels by zepearl on Friday October 05, 2018 @03:53PM (#18151175)
I just had a look for the first time at the description of levels 4 and 5 here (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-driving_car#Levels_of_dri...).

The definition of level 5 being "under all roadway and environmental conditions that can be managed by a human driver" means that whatever mechanism being used would have a better "brain" (at least in the area of "driving") than the human one, correct?

If yes: kind of scary, as such capability would probably have to include the comprehension/understanding of e.g. "context", the ability to "abstract", be able to generalize from indirecly related informations, etc.. to understand potential upcoming dangers.

For example when driving behind a truck which has its trailer that wobbles continuously left and right (but which can still keep its lane) because of a partially flat tire would probably need a very advanced AI to recognize the potential danger.

Re:US to Allow Cars Without Steering Wheels by krapp on Friday October 05, 2018 @07:57PM (#18152677)
Yes... the problem of autonomous cars is likely that of strong, general purpose AI.

Unfortunately, the politics around autonomous cars insists that human beings are basically idiots behind the wheel, so the problem seems more trivial than it is. After all, how hard can it be to design an AI smarter than an idiot?

Re:US to Allow Cars Without Steering Wheels by coldtea on Saturday October 06, 2018 @05:53AM (#18154345)
>For example when driving behind a truck which has its trailer that wobbles continuously left and right (but which can still keep its lane) because of a partially flat tire would probably need a very advanced AI to recognize the potential danger.

Or, say, driving in Mumbai or Beijing.

Re:US to Allow Cars Without Steering Wheels by ggggtez on Friday October 05, 2018 @03:04PM (#18150816)
I think it would be surprising if self driving cars didn't launch in the next 10 years. Consider that most people never drive more than 10 miles from their home on a given day. It's pretty trivial to imagine even "limited" AI vehicles being able to serve vast swaths of the population.

In that case, likely a lot of people would want to not have to invest in the hefty price of owning, maintaining, and insuring a vehicle, let alone driving which everyone knows is more dangerous than most things a person does in a given day.

Re:US to Allow Cars Without Steering Wheels by linuxftw on Friday October 05, 2018 @03:22PM (#18150974)
> Consider that most people never drive more than 10 miles from their home on a given day.

This is simply untrue if you're considering average commute distance of drivers in major cities.

> hefty price of owning, maintaining, and insuring a vehicle

These costs are highly variable, and many reasonable options are quite cheap.

I don't see self-driving cars catching on any time soon in the US. Possibly in Europe. I think they will be limited to smaller vehicles that operate in glorified bike lines, only on known routes.

Re:US to Allow Cars Without Steering Wheels by Falling3 on Friday October 05, 2018 @04:02PM (#18151243)
> This is simply untrue if you're considering average commute distance of drivers in major cities.

I'm sure that'd be correct if you'd said suburbs and rural areas, but according to this[0], the average commute for almost every major city is under 10 miles.

[0] https://www.marketwatch.com/story/here-are-the-typical-commu...

Re:US to Allow Cars Without Steering Wheels by jaxtellerSoA on Friday October 05, 2018 @04:20PM (#18151397)
>In that case, likely a lot of people would want to not have to invest in the hefty price of owning, maintaining, and insuring a vehicle, let alone driving which everyone knows is more dangerous than most things a person does in a given day.

All of the costs are worth it, as long as I don't have to share transportation with anyone else.

Re:US to Allow Cars Without Steering Wheels by coldtea on Saturday October 06, 2018 @05:55AM (#18154350)
>It's pretty trivial to imagine even "limited" AI vehicles being able to serve vast swaths of the population.

Or, god forbid, public transport with an actual bus driver...

Re:US to Allow Cars Without Steering Wheels by jaxtellerSoA on Friday October 05, 2018 @04:18PM (#18151377)
You'll have to rip the keys from my cold dead hands.
Re:US to Allow Cars Without Steering Wheels by jolmg on Friday October 05, 2018 @07:01PM (#18152429)
Even if self-driving cars become the norm in developed countries, there is no way they'll be so in the rest of the world.

In many places, there are no lines drawn on the road and you have to imagine the lanes. It could be a space big enough for 3 or 4 lanes. It makes me wonder if cars would recognize the general direction of the road and not drive diagonally through the imaginary lanes when there's a turn.

Some lanes may also have horrible holes that seem like they could easily take your wheel off if you fall on them with speed. Sometimes they're sinkholes, other times they're part of a construction job that was left midway for months seemingly until someone has a horrible accident. Some lanes look like they're at risk of becoming large sinkholes, and you'd rather avoid them lest the whole car suddenly falls meters below the ground. For both of these, you know they're there, and you know they're basically unavoidable once they become visible. How would you communicate these risks to the car?

Jaywalkers on high-speed, high-traffic highways might be common due to lack of bridges or any other alternative to crossing the road. They coordinate their movements with the incoming traffic and the drivers also coordinate their movements with them. Behaving unexpectedly, like simply changing lanes, even at a distance, could be fatal because it changes the shape of the incoming traffic the jaywalkers depend on once they decided to start crossing. Emergency stopping might worsen the situation when tailgaters are common.

Pedestrians might also be suicidal and you might be able to discern their intent from a distance by watching their behavior, but the car is not going to interpret that and it'll get close enough for the pedestrian to throw themselves at the road when it can't avoid them.

Advancing when a streetlight becomes green might generally be unsafe in zones where it's common for cars to cross at high speeds when the light is about to or just turned red. Would cars be on the lookout for high speed traffic coming from the left or right at a distance?

Simply put, there's lots to be on the look out for, especially when pedestrian city infrastructure, vehicle city infrastructure, traffic law enforcement, driving education, etc. is lacking. If self-driving cars become the norm in developed countries, I think it'd be in great part because they're not lacking in any of these things, and the car software can deal with a somewhat consistent environment. That wouldn't be the case elsewhere, though.

As to what my opinion is on the issue at hand, as a software developer, I wouldn't put so much trust in software as to not have a way to take manual control when this software has the ability to bring physical harm or death to me and others. Even disregarding the possibility of malice through malware and assuming whatever code that executes was written with the best intentions, there's just too many ways for things to go wrong in this problem domain and the consequences can be deadly.

Good design lies in simplicity. I cannot imagine the behemoth of code that must be required to implement safe automated driving. That's a lot to put faith in when lives are on the line.