But with the GPL, all future modifications to the code are required to also be GPL. You cannot make a closed-source fork of a GPL'd project.
A third party can’t, but the copyright holder can. That’s why some companies release GPL’d software with a closed commercial version.
We can generally trust the FSF not to, but copyright gives you that right.
It's the FSF's commitment (mentioned upthread) to not do that which arguably makes it safe to sign a CLA with the FSF.