News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:IQ Matters Less Than You Think by cm2187 on Thursday October 04, 2018 @09:56AM (#18139890)
True but you are assuming the IQ test is inifinitely precise which I doubt it is. It is only a measure of intelligence.
Re:IQ Matters Less Than You Think by toasterlovin on Thursday October 04, 2018 @10:39AM (#18140280)
I'm not really assuming it's very precise. It's more that there's a huge difference between 99th percentile levels of talent and 99.99th percentile levels of talent. For instance, I am easily better than 99/100 males at basketball. I'm 6'6", reasonably athletic, and I played semi-competitively when I was young. But I am nowhere near being better than 9,999/10,000 males. And no amount of hard work or persistence is going to change that.
Re:IQ Matters Less Than You Think by SiempreViernes on Thursday October 04, 2018 @12:02PM (#18141087)
The objection was that you can't reliably tell apart the 99 from the 99.99 percentile with a common IQ test.
Re:IQ Matters Less Than You Think by WorkLifeBalance on Thursday October 04, 2018 @12:39PM (#18141454)
The difference between 99th and 99.99th percentile is 1.4 standard deviations, a common IQ test ought to be able to be accurate to that. Otherwise it couldn't measure the difference between 100 and 120 IQ (0 to 1.4z) which it clearly can.
Re:IQ Matters Less Than You Think by gjm11 on Thursday October 04, 2018 @03:12PM (#18142728)
I don't think your reasoning is valid. A test might be unable to discriminate accurately at the extremes not because it's uniformly too inaccurate but because it doesn't have enough range.

Toy model: the test consists of one question that everyone in the top 1% can do and no one in the bottom 99% can do; one question that everyone in the top 2% can do and no one in the bottom 98% can do; ... one question that everyone in the top 99% can do and no one in the bottom 1% can do. This test discriminates very nicely and accurately throughout its range of applicability, but it will do no good at all from distinguishing a top-0.01% person from a merely top-1% person.

(Just as a tape measure 2m long will let you compare people very accurately by height provided they're no taller than 2m, but will be much less useful for people taller than that.)

Re:IQ Matters Less Than You Think by WorkLifeBalance on Friday October 05, 2018 @05:00AM (#18146702)
Modern tests are delivered by computer and typically are adaptive. This means that as you answer questions correctly you get asked increasingly difficult questions until you get some wrong.

This means that you aren't limited to asking the same questions to everyone so you can have appropriate discrimination through the range.

Re:IQ Matters Less Than You Think by diminoten on Thursday October 04, 2018 @12:55PM (#18141577)
> a common IQ test ought to be able to be accurate to that

Accurate to what, even? The very notion of IQ is fuzzy, so naturally any test trying to measure the value would inherit that fuzziness.

The difference between 100 and 120 may be statistically identical to 99 and 99.99, but the practical difference is vastly different. At a certain point, the IQ test is "defeated", and any value above a certain threshold is nose.

Re:IQ Matters Less Than You Think by SiempreViernes on Thursday October 04, 2018 @01:49PM (#18142031)
Sorry, I don't understand: how do you know the percentile difference in terms of standard deviations but not know if a test is accurate enough?
Re:IQ Matters Less Than You Think by LukeShu on Thursday October 04, 2018 @02:02PM (#18142130)
By assuming that it's a normal distribution.
Re:IQ Matters Less Than You Think by npunt on Thursday October 04, 2018 @06:01PM (#18144052)
An answer, by analogy-

If you yell into a microphone, the recording will come out distorted and inaccurate. Yet if you speak normally into one, the recording will sound rather true to life. This is because the microphone has been tuned to a certain level of sensitivity, and when that threshold is exceeded, what it records is clipped.

A similar principle holds for many types of human tests in education, psych, etc.

Re:IQ Matters Less Than You Think by jojoo on Thursday October 04, 2018 @10:15AM (#18140049)
they are very not precise. Most give a 80% confidence interval of +- 8 Points (or 1/2 STD). Also the different tests measure slightly different types of intelligence/put emphasis on other things. There's only ~0.8 correlation between modern IQ tests.
Re:IQ Matters Less Than You Think by opportune on Thursday October 04, 2018 @08:55PM (#18144880)
Yes, in fact, because it's generally calibrated to the whole human population and is defined on an assumed bell curve, the differences in scores in the outliers are somewhat meaningless