News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:That sign telling you how fast you’re driving may be capt... by loser777 on Thursday October 04, 2018 @04:51AM (#18138197)
Enforcing speed when the intent is public safety rather than revenue generation requires more nuance than what the current system in the US has to offer.

Does it make sense to strictly enforce a 20 or 25 mph limit in areas with residential/pedestrian traffic? Certainly, especially given that pedestrians crossing a street are essentially at a 25 mph speed difference relative to perpendicular traffic. But if we apply this arithmetic to semi trailers traveling at 65 mph on the highway, a 25 mph difference would suggest a speed limit of 90 mph, even neglecting the safety difference in a vehicle-vehicle collision.

Where are most current speeding tickets issued? Is it in low-speed, residential areas where drivers know that an extra 5 mph won't save them any time at all (and would greatly increase the risk of injury in an accident)? Or is it in high-speed straights on the highway where an extra 15 mph can save you hours on long trips (where a speed limit effectively grandfathered from the malaise era still applies)?

Another consideration: if speed enforcement on highways was so critical to public safety, why are radar detectors and even laser jammers legal in many US jurisdictions? My perception is that physics-based policy decisions never get far in the US system. Ultimately, automated enforcement/better technology seems orthogonal to the policy problem. We should get the policy right first.

Re:That sign telling you how fast you’re driving may be capt... by imgabe on Thursday October 04, 2018 @06:18AM (#18138565)
> Is it in low-speed, residential areas where drivers know that an extra 5 mph won't save them any time at all (and would greatly increase the risk of injury in an accident)?

Based on my personal experience in such areas, drivers very much do not know this. The number of people speeding down residential streets in my city just to get to a red light at the end of a block is astonishing.

Re:That sign telling you how fast you’re driving may be capt... by fyfy18 on Thursday October 04, 2018 @06:23AM (#18138588)
For a comparison, the other week I drove 4000km across Europe and most of the speed cameras I came across were in areas where the speed actually makes a difference i.e. in towns and residential areas. Along a three lane motorway it doesn’t make much difference whether you go at 130kmh or 160kmh, if you aren’t paying attention and do something stupid it’s going to end badly either way. From seeing where speed was actually enforced, it seems that the authorities here believe that too.
Re:That sign telling you how fast you’re driving may be capt... by hoppelhase on Thursday October 04, 2018 @06:50AM (#18138721)
In Germany, speed cameras are placed where accidents are likely to occur when the speed limit is exceeded.
Re:That sign telling you how fast you’re driving may be capt... by upofadown on Thursday October 04, 2018 @08:50AM (#18139393)
There is nothing in the article suggesting that the license plate readers in the signs would be used for speed enforcement. The big problem here is that the cameras are intended to be secret. Openly using license plate readers for actual speed enforcement raises much less serious issues as there are politically enforced limits on what the data can be used for.
Re:That sign telling you how fast you’re driving may be capt... by maxerickson on Thursday October 04, 2018 @07:31AM (#18138918)
Truck speed limits are lower than other vehicles exactly because of physics. Your suggestion that the speed difference is the thing that should be consistent across scenarios doesn't account for physics though. Kinetic energy goes with the square of speed, so the thing to look at is stopping distance from a given speed.
Re:That sign telling you how fast you’re driving may be capt... by jacquesm on Thursday October 04, 2018 @07:32AM (#18138926)
Most speeding in residential areas (both in frequency and in delta relative to the limit) is done by the people that live there. There was quite a bit of research done regarding this and one of the conclusions that stood out for me was that the familiarity with the territory was a big factor in this.