News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Black holes ruled out as universe’s missing dark matter by nautilus12 on Tuesday October 02, 2018 @10:28PM (#18127229)
Does this mean that black holes possibly might not even exist? Aren't there examples of them being directly observed?
Re:Black holes ruled out as universe’s missing dark matter by TrainedMonkey on Tuesday October 02, 2018 @10:43PM (#18127288)
No black holes absolutely exist. The researches have established an upper limit on the fraction of mass of black holes compared to all of the matter in universe. Per quote below this comes out to no more than than 23%.

" An as-yet unpublished reanalysis by the same team using an updated list of 1,048 supernovas cuts the limit in half, to a maximum of about 23 percent, further slamming the door on the dark matter-black hole proposal. "

Since dark matter makes up 85% of total matter this rules out black holes as the primary contributor.

Re:Black holes ruled out as universe’s missing dark matter by sulam on Tuesday October 02, 2018 @10:37PM (#18127264)
We have observed their x-ray jets directly and have observed their creation (recently). Pretty sure they exist. :)
Re:Black holes ruled out as universe’s missing dark matter by oldandtired on Tuesday October 02, 2018 @11:12PM (#18127383)
Let's change this a little bit.

We have observed specific phenomena but not that which created such phenomena.

As far as "Black Holes" as per theoretical descriptions are concerned, they cannot exist in a finite time universe as far as we (the observers) are concerned. The theoretical models used all have as a basic assumption that increasing gravity (whatever that may be) will cause a slow down in time as observed at distances away from such increase. As such, all phenomena involved in the creation of such entities will slow to a complete stop as far as we are concerned.

Hence, if the universe is of any finite duration, we will not have seen the creation of even 1 black hole of any kind. On the other hand, if the universe has existed eternally, it is still likely that these entities are still in the process of formation and not yet in existence.

I don't doubt we are seeing some interesting phenomena, but not the entities called "Black Holes". The argument for the creation involves changing perspective to some observer who is falling into or through the event horizon (choose which one of these you want, as there are apparently a couple of choices here in the theoretical models). Since we are not such observers, that perspective is actually irrelevant to us. What is relevant is what we observe in the universe at large.

The basic problems (irrespective of mathematical assumptions) with the processes of "Black Hole" generation relate to non-uniformity of compression, time dilation and other basic assumptions for the "Black Hole" models.

I find the reasoning used for the existence of "Black Holes" in our universe to be lacking in logical rigour and appears to have a lot of hand-waviness to it.

I am currently reading the documentation for the Metamath system and there are some quite enlightening comments in that about mathematics and those who study it. Especially as it relates to us who are not mathematicians as our career. One of these relates to the amount of "faith" we have to exhibit when trusting that specific "proofs" are in point of fact true. Even mathematicians who are not in that specific speciality do not have the necessary background to verify any proof outside of their own mathematical area.

Mathematics is a profoundly useful tool but as we have seen in the past and we will see in the future, it has problems (like all areas).

Re:Black holes ruled out as universe’s missing dark matter by InclinedPlane on Tuesday October 02, 2018 @11:53PM (#18127522)
We have observed matter falling into a black hole. We've watched "hot spots" in orbit of a black hole in the accretion disk shine their light at us as they orbited the black hole. We've watched as the orbit got tighter and tighter and the light was dimmed by gravitational red shifting, then we've watched the light blink out and disappear as the blob of gas fell below the event horizon.

The evidence for the existence of black holes is incredibly strong at the moment. In fact in some ways it's stronger than the evidence for the existence of atoms about a century ago. Nobody except cranks or extreme contrarians seriously disputes the theory these days.

Re:Black holes ruled out as universe’s missing dark matter by TeMPOraL on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @02:50AM (#18128112)
Then there's this video ESO's Very Large Telescope shot[0], of stars orbiting something that's a) very massive, and b) invisible. Does that constitute a direct observation of a black hole?

--

[0] - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TF8THY5spmo

Re:Black holes ruled out as universe’s missing dark matter by perl4ever on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @12:25AM (#18127615)
From your point of view, if so-called black holes are "fuzzballs"[1] is that a vindication or a refutation of the existence of black holes? Without a deep understanding of physics, I have the general attitude that infinities must be a mathematical error, and therefore something must stop black holes from collapsing totally, but whether they "exist" is only a matter of definitions.

[1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fuzzball_(string_theory)

Re:Black holes ruled out as universe’s missing dark matter by roywiggins on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @10:01AM (#18130242)
I tend to agree with you. Are mathematical singularities physical? We just don't know. I think probably not on philosophical grounds. But we can't peek inside an event horizon to find out, and these event horizons seem to exist, so whatever the structure of the insides of them are, they're still black holes.
Re:Black holes ruled out as universe’s missing dark matter by roywiggins on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @12:12AM (#18127567)
I believe the argument is that event horizons exist but inside is not a singularity, but an eternally collapsing mass of the original star. From the point of view of the star, it does collapse all the way, but from our point of view that final singularity collapse is in the indefinite future.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnetospheric_eternally_col...

Re:Black holes ruled out as universe’s missing dark matter by roywiggins on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @09:57AM (#18130209)
Update: I am mistaken. The classic GR black hole behaves this way. MECOs supposedly never fully collapse into a singularity, even for infalling observers. That's the difference.

I rather think we'd have noticed the difference from LIGO gravitational wave measurements of BH mergers, but maybe not?

Re:Black holes ruled out as universe’s missing dark matter by oldandtired on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @03:16AM (#18128203)
No. Incorrect. Wildly inaccurate.

We have made certain observations that are assumed to be the result of matter falling into a "Black Hole". We do not have any observations that show us this as a fact. Read the observational material very carefully.

Go back over the last few decades and see how many times it is declared "we have seen x for the first time", where x is the is the same entity each time, in this particlualr case "Black Holes".

Men (women, children) want to believe that they have a certain handle on the truth and reality. What is very unpleasant to most is not having that certainty. This applies to all people across the board and even more so to those whose expertise is dependent on their being right. Many scientists are in this category.

It is often difficult to sit in the place of recognising that we just don't know. We have some ideas which, on the evidence, give a handle to investigate further, but we should understand that our understanding can be turned on its head.

The evidence for the existence of something is there, yes. But, is it a "Black Hole" of the theory presented, hmmm, that is unknown and for the time being, unknowable. As we cannot get out there and actually do the appropriate experiments to test this. We can only do remote observations and these can be easily misinterpreted.

>>Nobody except cranks or extreme contrarians seriously disputes the theory these days.

The problem here with this view is that it has been "cranks" and "extreme contrarians" who have brought about the biggest changes in science. There are Nobel Prize winners amongst them. All views about the nature of our universe should have those who dispute it. This should spur on our investigations into the nature of the universe. If we are unable to handle someone disputing our models and theories of the universe, then what are we doing? We are not serious about expanding our knowledge, we are serious about our reputations and being right.

The biggest problem for science today is that people don't trust it because it keeps getting things wrong, yet all the while saying that it is the only source of truth.

Science is one of a group of tools we can and should use to investigate the universe around. It has its limitations as does all the other tools we have and we need to recognise that though this tool is helpful in understanding, it is not the tool that gives us the truth.

Re:Black holes ruled out as universe’s missing dark matter by SiempreViernes on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @05:50AM (#18128826)
You had like, a slim case before GW150914. Now you just have to either accept that black holes (in the sense of the external metric predicted by GR) do exist, or go make friends with the climate change deniers.

The science discussion about the existence is settled, as evidenced by your complete lack of any concrete objection to the interpretations. (Just saying "measuring is ambiguous, maybe we didn't understand it properly" like it is an objection is typical cranking)

Re:Black holes ruled out as universe’s missing dark matter by oldandtired on Thursday October 04, 2018 @07:46AM (#18138992)
You really need to read the information provided about GW150914. There is no direct observation of the event, irrespective of what LIGO might say about the matter, LIGO is an indirect methodology.

I have no doubt that something was observed, but what that was will take far more research and repeated events that can be backed up by other observational means before we have any real evidence before us.

The science is only settled for those who want certainty in their models and theories. For practical uses, one can believe that electrons exist and act in particular ways and we build "technology" based on those "beliefs". Yet, we still do not have any real handle on what these particular entities are.

I used to believe in "black holes" and other assorted entities. I had no problems with these things, until I started noticing the discrepancies. It made me take a longer look and I realised that we know far less than we think and we understand far less than we think we do.

I live country that experiences climate change, yet, what I find interesting is that if you have questions about whether or not it is anthropogenic, you are immediately classified as a denier. The same goes for many different areas in science. If you don't accept the dogma you have to be a "crank".

What science needs is a higher level of scepticism than what it currently has.

Too many of the "settled" things are not "settled" at all. We have barely scratched the surface of the universe around us and the major failing we have is this desire to be certain. There are huge amounts of experimental observations that are showing that we really have no clue and an enormous number of new models are being developed as the years go by.

Re:Black holes ruled out as universe’s missing dark matter by SiempreViernes on Thursday October 04, 2018 @01:30PM (#18141877)
Look, to do science you have to believe the world outside your head can be observed; and if you are ready to trust the rickety and convoluted stack that encodes pulses from a keyboard into photons from a screen to accurately convey information, then gravity waves have been observed and match predictions for black holes exactly.

If you want to stick to reading Gorgias of Leontini that is fine, but please don't bother the rest of us that do accept the world outside as real.

Re:Black holes ruled out as universe’s missing dark matter by oldandtired on Friday October 05, 2018 @06:15AM (#18146965)
You miss the point of what I am saying. Observations are being made, but is the given explanation actually meaningful? The universe is real. This does not mean that our explanations or interpretations are "truth". The problem I have with the current mindset is that it trends to treating others with a different viewpoint, model or theory as being unworthy of consideration, to be treated as pariahs, imbeciles, crackpots, heretics, to be hunted down and assassinated.

We should be accepting that our models and theories are both incomplete and wrong, irrespective of how useful they are. Every model and theory has its points of failure. That should be expected and is not a problem. Starting from that basis, we keep investigating to get better models or theories that help us gain a better insight into the universe around us. If that means giving up one model for something completely else, then what's the problem. Our universe is beautiful, complex, a place of incredible wonder that we can have an exciting time exploring and discovery.

There is a vast difference between the reality of the universe and what our models and theories are. The first is the territory, the second is only a map and maps can be notoriously faulty.

In regards to your reference to Gorgias of Leontini, I had to look that up. I chuckled. Is it possible that some of the "superstars" of science today are modern students of him?

Re:Black holes ruled out as universe’s missing dark matter by InclinedPlane on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @04:22AM (#18128469)
If you're trying to get me to take you seriously you've failed. Do you think that condescension mingled with evidence free assertions are the way to support an argument? Is that science in your eyes?
Re:Black holes ruled out as universe’s missing dark matter by oldandtired on Thursday October 04, 2018 @08:32AM (#18139284)
Who am I to be taken seriously? The condescension is a part of the attitude of those who consider something "settled". You made the claim that we have observed matter falling into a "black hole". The evidence that you didn't present says we have some observations, but only supposition as to what it means.

In your eyes, that evidence may be "beyond a reasonable doubt", but from my perspective, that evidence barely scratches the surface of what we need.

Science is not about dogma, it is about investigating the universe about in a systematic way and looking at all sorts of models and theories that can provide a handle on understanding.

But none of those models or theories will ever be the "truth". They can be adequate for the purposes needed, but outside of those limited areas, other models will be required. These other models will give a better description and handle within their limits. For all the desire for a "theory of everything", it will not be achieved. There will always be anomalous observations.

Whether you agree or disagree, that is simply your choice and anything I say will be seen through your filters and biases. That is what happens to all of us.

You can believe that GR is the "bee's knees", I can believe differently. You can believe in little blue fairies living at the bottom of your garden, if you like. I put little blue fairies in the same basket as "black holes".

We have lots of very interesting observations of lots of very interesting things out there. I just have problems with the inconsistencies of the models used to describe these things.

Re:Black holes ruled out as universe’s missing dark matter by ajuc on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @04:37AM (#18128538)
> We have made certain observations that are assumed to be the result of matter falling into a "Black Hole". We do not have any observations that show us this as a fact.

Do you believe in gravity? We've never observed it directly, always just its effects.

Re:Black holes ruled out as universe’s missing dark matter by oldandtired on Thursday October 04, 2018 @07:59AM (#18139056)
I believe in the observational effects of something we call gravity. As to its nature, that is still unknown. GR is one model/theory and it works most of the time. But there are observations that do not fit into this model. That is the sticking point - these observation suggest that, though GR is useful, it is seriously flawed.

Can we use it, yes. But to believe that it is true, that is something quite different.

Re:Black holes ruled out as universe’s missing dark matter by AgentME on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @12:11AM (#18127566)
Black holes may not form true singularities in any finite amount of time, but event horizons that are indistinguishable from the outside can be formed.
Re:Black holes ruled out as universe’s missing dark matter by oldandtired on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @02:44AM (#18128100)
It is the event horizon that never forms. The problem that is never dealt with is that when the density of material goes up, gravity goes up, time dilation throughout all the affected material increases. From our perspective, everything throughout the affected material and region slows down - that includes any compression effects to increase the density. There is no opportunity for the effects to generate an event horizon to occur in finite time. If the event horizon cannot form then you can forget about any singularity ever forming.

It is just assumed that the event horizon and all of the associated effects will occur in finite time. It is taken as a given that "Black Holes" exist without questioning all of the assumptions being made regarding these entities. When anyone questions this view, the amount of disdain and ridicule expressed to them is just ridiculous.

Those expressing such disdain and ridicule do not even attempt to answer the questions - it is immediate ad hominen attack. This is the attitude that encouraged me to investigate the matter further and the conclusion is that those experts who support the idea of "Black Holes" have a mindset of "we are the authority and who are you to question us". They are so blinded by there own brilliance that they cannot see the forest because they have their noses up against the ground. It is a sorry state of affairs when dogma gets in the road of investigation.

There are no stupid questions, ever. However, there are many non-answers given.

Re:Black holes ruled out as universe’s missing dark matter by AgentME on Friday October 05, 2018 @06:04PM (#18152108)
The event horizon might never "complete" in finite time either, but from the outside it can become increasingly indistinguishable from a complete event horizon over time as the black hole's mass compresses along the surface of the event horizon. Light escapes from the mass less and much less often over time. Black holes were originally often called "frozen stars" to emphasize how from our point of view, the mass never quite made it into the interior of the event horizon. Relevant: https://astronomy.stackexchange.com/a/14239.

It seems like you're just placing restrictions on the term "black hole" that no one else is.