I surprised a fellow developer in the Dark Mists MUD by converting a table into a simple linear formula ("What should Y be when X is at this point in the range?"); this is grade school geometry, right? I just needed the formula for a line!
In my regular work, it is surprising how many times people do not understand the need for variance or standard deviation when they are looking for quality in averages of their data sets.
So web programming? If you have to put up charts of large data sets, things will get hairy without at least knowing how to interpolate the data points. A slow website may be a result of brute-force simplistic approaches in the code. Some of the packages we use (such as jQuery) require some good math knowledge to implement (example: drag-and-drop). We certainly cannot generalize that in web programming, it is acceptable to not know math.
You can get away with not using math in our industry if you leave it to others to do it for you.
Many people grab a scientific toolkit (psipy and the like), but understanding what a Gaussian filter is vs calling a function for it, does an immeasurable amount of good anytime you need to decide what your particular dataset needs.
The other thing is taste. If you are quite good at math you will like those jobs where math is involved. Unfortunatelly this can hurt if you have only have some mundane programming job. I certainly cannot use my theoretical knowledge at my job, I can only use it in side projects. I know a mathematician with orders of magnitudes bigger math knowledge than me: his taste is so abstract that even tasks which I find exciting are boring to him. His taste is so abstract that he is excited about only theoretical math reasearch. He is a researcher mathematician and he don't create any programs at all and his research is not really related to practical things.
I know programmers who have smaller math knowledge than me but are more passionate about their day job than me and perhaps they are even more productive for this reason at their day job (which is the same as mine.) Passion is more important than knowledge.
So if you want to be a good and happy web developer I think there IS something like too much math knowledge.
I don't know what kind of programming the author does, but I was sending such a letter to myself, I would absolutely not say 'Its ok to suck at math'.
I'd be much more likely to tell myself: "Don't worry so much about learning about hardware specifics - spend lots of time on abstract math, it'll come in handy all sorts of places later".
As commented in another reply:
... Never used more than a trivial amount of the math
content, but the math processes of thought have been
invaluable.
In spades.How many people are crap at something, realise they can get along without it, and thereby conclude that it's useless? Most. It's like being incompetent and unaware of it. It's an unknown unknown.
The reverse is also true. If you know a lot of math, you don't really know how you might have gotten along as a programmer without it.
You might know that you would have struggled at the mathy programming you have done, but you wouldn't necessarily know if you would have excelled at other kinds of programming despite a lack of math depth.
I think your assumption is that people think like: I like programming. I'm bad at math. Math doesn't help my programming anyways.
Instead I think people think like: I like programming I'm bad at math, so I don't like it. I'm going to look at other fields to improve my programming.
I think the problem is, and the author hints at it, is that people tend to over glorify the importance of math at the expense of drowning out other fields, like prose.
In some fields like web programming, I would say that yes, my time is better spent learning how to write understandable code instead of how to solve complex equations. As a result, I probably won't ever program video games, but thats ok, games take a lot of math, and I wouldn't enjoy that anyways. It's not that I'm lazy and just don't want to get better at programming. I just want to get better at programming in ways that I enjoy the most.
With infinite time, I would certainly do it both.
I would say that yes, my time is better spent learning
how to write understandable code instead of how to
solve complex equations.
Math isn't about solving complex equations. Common mis-conception, totally wrong, very understandable for those whose experience of math is limited to calculus or pre-calculus.I don't solve complex equations, and yet I use math every day.
The problem I see is that people who might be really really good at advanced math are often completely turned off by high school math and the teaching thereof. Hence they never get the chance to see the really fun stuff that turns out to be useful in unexpected ways. Even more, I'd guess that the really good programmers who hate math are in that group.
I would so like to be able to test that hypothesis. There's a Ph.D. waiting in it.
That said, to re-summarize my point tersely: If someone doesn't like a particular field, I still feel that they can be successful programmers by focusing on fields that they do like which are also useful.
Can you explain what you mean by this?
In my experience, most people who go through math classes at a University, not to mention classes in High School, are mostly "blindly" following a template of how to do induction. They don't really understand the principle behind it, why it's a valid proof technique, etc. Put another way, if I used induction incorrectly, I could probably still trick them into thinking it's a valid proof because it looks like induction.
The same goes for a lot of things in Mathematics. The same also goes for recursion - most people don't really understand recursion (unless it's used at a "simple" level, like in Tree Recursion).
You mean like this one?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/All_horses_are_the_same_color
My college calculus professor used this example when she was teaching induction.
One of the best software engineers I know has a law degree and says exactly the same thing. So I suspect that the same is likely to be true for anybody else who's gotten a PhD or other advanced degree.
I would have thought they would be more useful for the sorts of things that programmers are bad at, like dealing with, or in, lies and half-truths. And not be so good for the 'long chains of precise reasoning' type problems.
Of course, you might equally say that being able to handle the political side of life 'makes you a better programmer', but I don't think you'd mean it in the same way.
Ideally you'd want both.
and yes, I do mean that being able to handle the social side of life (including politics) makes you a better programmer in the same way.
agreed that you want both.
It's OK not to have a PhD, it's OK not to have a degree, but at least knowing about, and having a good, intuitive grasp of what goes on in topology, linear algebra, analysis, graph theory, game theory, logic and more is immeasureably useful.
Unless you're doing the kind of coding that really doesn't require design or algorithms or data structures or communications or database work.
I've never used stuff I did in my PhD, but time and time again, continuously (and I use the work correctly, I don't mean continually) I've used the stuff I learned on the way that enabled me to do my PhD.
Learn more math. It will be useful, even if only to give you the option of rigorous reasoning.