News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Did I just waste 3 years? by jrochkind1 on Sunday September 30, 2018 @11:28PM (#18109830)
But... you still gotta pay for food and a place to live, start with, at the moment.

If we didn't have to worry about money, then fewer of us would have to... worry about money when making art.

Re:Did I just waste 3 years? by int_19h on Monday October 01, 2018 @01:20AM (#18110208)
In general, that is true. I should have been more specific:

> We now have enough people with skills, experience, tools, and free time necessary to produce a quality indie game and a desire to make one, that the market price is far below the cost of production, and rapidly approaching zero.

Where "free time" is that not used up by work that pays for food etc.

Which does mean that people for whom art is a hobby are destroying the market the people for whom art is all they want to do, except for truly great artists where the quality of the art is so exemplary that hobby artists just can't compete.

But I'm not sure why it's a bad thing in and of itself - nobody has a fundamental right to earn a living by performing some specific activity and no other. The job market defines what activities translate to paid jobs, and which ones can only be hobbies, and that is going to change over time. At the point of a true post-scarcity, everything becomes a hobby, but it doesn't matter because you no longer need a job.

Re:Did I just waste 3 years? by jrochkind1 on Monday October 01, 2018 @09:21AM (#18112268)
If you only hang out with people who have enough free time to fulfill their creative desires (mostly in good health, mostly without kids, mostly who have "good" jobs which in most cases means their parents did too, which probably means they aren't taking care of their parents or other family members either) it can seem like a widespread thing. In fact, it's not; most people, in the U.S., and especially globally, are hustling to survive.

post-scarcity can sound nice, but in practice it currently means post-scarcity for the few, while most people live with incredible scarcity. We might have enough for everyone on the planet, but we sure don't share it equally. And that's not going to change automatically.

Re:Did I just waste 3 years? by int_19h on Monday October 01, 2018 @04:21PM (#18116484)
To be clear, I'm not saying that it is widespread! But it is more widespread than it used to be, IMO - this sort of thing was historically confined to the elites, and now it's slowly creeping its way down middle class. Hence why I called it a manifestation of an ongoing march towards post-scarcity.

When and where the goal would actually be achieved is hard to speculate; I hope to see it in my lifetime, but only out of sheer optimism.

Re:Did I just waste 3 years? by jrochkind1 on Monday October 01, 2018 @04:31PM (#18116558)
> this sort of thing was historically confined to the elites, and now it's slowly creeping its way down middle class

I'm not sure that's true. I don't see much ongoing march towards giving most people more free time. Inequality is generally _growing_, not shrinking. There is no ongoing march of history, just humans in political struggle for how resources are distributed.

Re:Did I just waste 3 years? by int_19h on Tuesday October 02, 2018 @12:45AM (#18118860)
Relative inequality is growing. But in absolute terms, to be poor today is a great deal better than being poor 100 years. Conversely, this means that you are also more productive in absolute terms.

There's definitely a lot more free time available to people today than there were in any industrial economy prior to 8-hour work days and similar advancements in labor rights. If you unwind back to pre-industrial, some argue that agriculture provides for a lot more free time than we're used to, albeit seasonally.

But free time is only one part of the equation - you also need education/skills and tools to create things. These days, many industrialized societies provide education for free, or so cheap that it's accessible to a great deal more people than it used to be - and then, of course, there's the Internet. Tools are also much cheaper; again, think about it in absolute terms, e.g. how a $20 power drill compares to your typical toolset 100 years ago, much less 500.

Our societies have plenty of problems, and I don't encourage rose glasses. But we should also recognize just how immense the advance of humanity has really been, when you look in the rear mirror. Or not even the mirror... if you were born in a developed country, find an immigrant from a developing one, and just ask them how they feel about here vs there.

Re:Did I just waste 3 years? by jrochkind1 on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @05:37PM (#18135041)
> But in absolute terms, to be poor today is a great deal better than being poor 100 years.

In the U.S., certainly. In India or Nigeria or Honduras? Not sure.

At any rate, while I agree that in general the health and standard of living of many people is going up -- I lack your confidence that the amount of _free time_, and other resources necessary to produce creative work without compensation, that the majority of people on the planet has is going up or will continue to. It will for some.

Even in the U.S., do the poor have more free time to produce creative work than they did 100 years ago? I seriously doubt it.

Re:Did I just waste 3 years? by stubish on Monday October 01, 2018 @09:46AM (#18112431)
Absolutely. I predict that more and more Indy games will be created by the retired, and the starving. Same as happened with novels and other arts like painting and photography.
Re:Did I just waste 3 years? by jrochkind1 on Monday October 01, 2018 @01:58PM (#18115115)
don't forget the rich!