News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Elon Musk Settles SEC Fraud Charges by archagon on Saturday September 29, 2018 @05:51PM (#18103078)
> Derailing him to jail time or prison would be a net loss for humanity, however objectively and legally inconsistent it may be.

I hate this perspective. As a member of humanity, I want everyone to face equal justice, no matter how pivotal to a particular project or movement they may be. There will always be more visionaries.

Anything else will eventually and inevitably lead to violence.

Re:Elon Musk Settles SEC Fraud Charges by bitanarch on Saturday September 29, 2018 @06:10PM (#18103196)
It doesn't make sense to prosecute every violation with maximum penalties allowable under the law. It's just not how the legal system works.

e.g. Google was alleged to have illegally issued options to their employees back in 2004 by the SEC. If they prosecuted Google's board and officers with maximum penalty in a federal court (and the court allowed such nonsense), then both Larry and Sergey (and a bunch of executives) would end up with 5-year prison sentences before Google had a chance to go IPO. But such a course of action is obviously not in public interest - the amount of damage to investors and the public in general caused by the remedy would far outweigh whatever irregularities in option grants that Google committed.

And btw, the same securities laws also apply when you open a startup and raise funds or issue options. It's not "Oh but Google is rich and I'm poor these laws won't hit me". Quite a number of securities law violations don't require intent. A single filing error by your lawyers can mean you're already in violation (and, years in prison if you use the maximum penalty) - even if you're just a tiny startup with $100k.

Both prosecutors and courts have always been walking a fine line on what's considered fair for each particular circumstance. It's how it has always been.

Re:Elon Musk Settles SEC Fraud Charges by hn_throwaway_99 on Sunday September 30, 2018 @12:51AM (#18104522)
But that is not what the parent comment to yours was arguing. He wasn't asking for the maximum available penalty, he was just saying that, in essence, justice should be blind, and criminal penalties should not be lessened based on the wealth or power of the convicted.

Using your own example, he was basically saying that if someone with "a tiny startup with $100k" was guilty of the same crime, he should face the same penalties as Musk.

Re:Elon Musk Settles SEC Fraud Charges by anticensor on Sunday September 30, 2018 @01:34PM (#18107204)
> It doesn't make sense to prosecute every violation with maximum penalties allowable under the law. It's just not how the legal system works.

Tell that to muslims.

Re:Elon Musk Settles SEC Fraud Charges by phil21 on Saturday September 29, 2018 @07:55PM (#18103713)
> Anything else will eventually and inevitably lead to violence.

I agree, but why has punishment and enforcement become so utterly derailed from reality or just.... basic morality?

They went after Musk hard because it was a trivial slam-dunk no-effort case. For a tweet.

Then you look at truly evil people who have committed acts of outright fraud who walk due to simply playing the game the government wants you to.

So while I agree with your point, I have very large reservations with current enforcement institutions. Go after a high-performing unconventional guy like Musk who actually accomplishes things with the entire weight of the federal government - but let the parasitic bankers who caused actual damage with outright fraud in the real world completely skate because prosecution would have actually taken work and been career risky.

My limited experience with the enforcement arms of the federal government simply affirmed this point of view. They only care about themselves and their personal careers, and could care less about actually protecting the people or even remotely attempting to find justice.

But if you tweet something that harms some wealthy short sellers there will be hell to pay within weeks.

Yes, this is hyperbolic and could be articulated better - but it's been something I've been chewing on now for decades.

Re:Elon Musk Settles SEC Fraud Charges by gkoberger on Saturday September 29, 2018 @06:04PM (#18103166)
Sure, I'd agree with this argument if he sexually assaulted someone or got a DUI or something. Nobody is "too valuable to go to jail".

But jail time for a random tweet seems like overkill, and removing him from Tesla for this does feel like it would be a net negative. He was heavily fined, which seems more fair.

Re:Elon Musk Settles SEC Fraud Charges by moomin on Saturday September 29, 2018 @06:15PM (#18103224)
I’m not going to argue sentencing, but I feel it’s necessary to point out that Musk doesn’t get to make random tweets, especially about price-sensitive investor information. The SEC treats his account as a corporate mouthpiece and anything he says on it can be treated as an official statement. This isn’t his first rodeo: he should know this stuff off by heart. As it is, you have to wonder what other fiduciary duties he’s not up to speed on.
Re:Elon Musk Settles SEC Fraud Charges by FartyMcFarter on Saturday September 29, 2018 @07:10PM (#18103511)
> The SEC treats his account as a corporate mouthpiece

Because Tesla told everyone to treat his account as a corporate mouthpiece:

https://www.cnbc.com/2018/08/08/reuters-america-update-7-u-s...

"Tesla alerted investors in a 2013 SEC filing that they should follow Musk's Twitter feed for "additional information" about the company."

Re:Elon Musk Settles SEC Fraud Charges by sosborn on Saturday September 29, 2018 @06:10PM (#18103197)
> jail time for a random tweet

Yeah, it isn't like he was out there randomly accusing people of being pedophiles or anything.

Re:Elon Musk Settles SEC Fraud Charges by InTheArena on Saturday September 29, 2018 @05:55PM (#18103106)
He did just pay for his mistakes, so everyone (except Elon) is a winner here.

Elon needs someone to act as a brake from time to time. Like shotwell at SpaceX..

Re:Elon Musk Settles SEC Fraud Charges by archagon on Saturday September 29, 2018 @05:58PM (#18103118)
I was responding more to the sentiment than this to particular case. Glad Musk was held accountable.
Re:Elon Musk Settles SEC Fraud Charges by TomMckenny on Saturday September 29, 2018 @06:14PM (#18103220)
Then the punishment for misleading consumers and employees should be comparable to the punishment for misleading investors.
Re:Elon Musk Settles SEC Fraud Charges by thaumaturgy on Saturday September 29, 2018 @06:03PM (#18103154)
I'm somewhat ashamed for feeling compelled to disagree. I know the right thing is to agree completely with you. Justice should be blind, and I've complained about that in other cases.

At the same time, it seems these days that there are so few people really working for the advancement of humanity to the extent that Musk is. (And just to try to abort the inevitable replies: yeah, I get that he isn't a saint, and yeah, he's done some pretty stupid, ugly, awful things.)

You're right that there will always be more visionaries, but the ones that are capable of executing grand visions that improve humanity seem to only roll around once a generation or so. They absolutely shouldn't be given a pass for terrible behavior, but I hate to see society so eager to tear at them, too.

Re:Elon Musk Settles SEC Fraud Charges by perl4ever on Saturday September 29, 2018 @06:02PM (#18103149)
I'm not particularly a fan of Musk, but the purported objective of SEC enforcement is to protect investors. If (as I read a day or two ago) the stock plunged on news of enforcement, then it's reasonable to question whether punishing him makes sense. Are the stockholders really better off with less (or no) Musk? Maybe, but does the SEC know better than the market? In any case, I'm not sure how or if "equal justice" is relevant.
Re:Elon Musk Settles SEC Fraud Charges by ryan_j_naughton on Saturday September 29, 2018 @06:12PM (#18103205)
The SEC isn't there to simply "protect investors". Your implication is the investors worth protecting are those with long positions. What about the shorts?

The SEC are there to protect the integrity of the market. Things like fraudulent information, insider trading, etc are corrosive to the mechanisms which a well functioning market requires.

Re:Elon Musk Settles SEC Fraud Charges by perl4ever on Saturday September 29, 2018 @06:30PM (#18103291)
"Your implication is the investors worth protecting are those with long positions"

Maybe there should be a bias towards those who benefit from the continuing viability of the company and maybe not.

But in this case, I suggest it's moot just because the damage to longs appeared to be significantly greater than the damage to shorts and it doesn't counterbalance anyway.

The penalties seem arbitrary to me. Transferring several million (or billion) dollars around as they are doing doesn't seem to rectify in any way the purported injustice to shorts. The whole episode drove down the stock quite a bit, so longs have suffered a lot, shorts have suffered somewhat, and the government collected a commission. Nobody has had wrongs rectified, and it's unknown whether prying Musk away from Tesla is a net gain.

Personally, I was neither long nor short TSLA at the time of the tweet, and I don't think short sellers are inherently illegitimate. However, I think the existence of a public company generally serves a social purpose and long investors are not quite symmetric with short investors. If, in general, there is a dispute where you can apply long investors' concept of fairness, or you can apply short investors' concept of fairness, it kind of makes sense that what damages the company less is probably the right answer, barring something like Theranos that shouldn't exist at all.

Re:Elon Musk Settles SEC Fraud Charges by rayiner on Saturday September 29, 2018 @06:06PM (#18103173)
Like most laws their purpose is normative. The point is to stop the next dozen CEOs from doing something like this.
Re:Elon Musk Settles SEC Fraud Charges by perl4ever on Saturday September 29, 2018 @06:36PM (#18103328)
I'm not sure deterrence is applicable. Someone commented in an earlier thread that Musk is slightly bipolar/manic at times. Fining him is not going to deter him from having symptoms, nor will letting him go encourage another person to have such symptoms. Your theory seems like spanking your child for catching the flu.

Of course, it might be that his tweets are being considered in the larger context of recent irresponsible tweeting by those in power, and thus from the perspective of enforcement it looks like a rising tide.

Re:Elon Musk Settles SEC Fraud Charges by perl4ever on Saturday September 29, 2018 @06:51PM (#18103412)
I also want to suggest, for all the people who want to say "what about the shorts", that every share of stock you sell short is borrowed from somebody who is long. So that seems like a fundamental reason to not consider shorts equal and opposite counterparts of longs. Whatever the details of the defined rights of both parties are, the rights of shorts have to defer to the rights of longs to some extent.

By analogy, if you borrow a car, and your interests seriously conflict with the owner, then probably for the good of society, and the rental market, there needs to be protection of the owner's rights.

Re:Elon Musk Settles SEC Fraud Charges by travmatt on Saturday September 29, 2018 @06:20PM (#18103246)
You’re trying to define investors as only people owning Tesla stock. The SEC specifies the penalties will go to investors hurt by Musks actions, which I take to mean stock market investors who Elon targeted by using his position as ceo to spread information that he knew to be misleading in order to harm their positions. It doesn’t really make sense to try and define ‘equal justice’ from the vantage point of those people who were helped by the illegal actions in question.
Re:Elon Musk Settles SEC Fraud Charges by perl4ever on Saturday September 29, 2018 @06:43PM (#18103362)
You (and others) seem to assume there's a zero-sum game between long and short investors and I'm neglecting the interests of the shorts.

I don't think it follows that what harms longs benefits the shorts that were harmed by Musk's tweets. So there is no benefit to compare to the harm done by the enforcement.

Unless you think that reducing Musk's role in the company will lead to the downfall of the company and that is a good thing because someone will profit, which seems like a weird idea to me.

Re:Elon Musk Settles SEC Fraud Charges by travmatt on Saturday September 29, 2018 @07:48PM (#18103680)
I think Elon Musk knowingly misled the public in order to harm the financial positions of certain investors - and it seems his settlement with the SEC indicates that he accepts those charges against him. I think it’s inappropriate for companies in the public market to be led by individuals who attempt such fraud, and it seems like both Elon Musk and the SEC have the same opinion. I think much more harm would be done to the financial markets if people are allowed to commit fraud without repercussions - the settlement, again, wasn’t reached by considering how to best ensure Elon musk and Tesla remain profitable, it was made in consideration of how to dissuade other ceo’s in committing similar frauds.
Re:Elon Musk Settles SEC Fraud Charges by yourbandsucks on Saturday September 29, 2018 @06:00PM (#18103131)
Would you have sacrificed the Apollo program for that sentiment? Genuine question. I'm conflicted myself.
Re:Elon Musk Settles SEC Fraud Charges by Invictus0 on Saturday September 29, 2018 @06:04PM (#18103158)
Absolutely. Even if it Apollo failed and it took 50 more years for humanity to reach the moon, these are small numbers on the scale of human history. Jailing Musk wouldn't mean humanity is forever unable to have electric cars or go to Mars. As another HN user quoted recently, the graveyards are filled with indispensable men.
Re:Elon Musk Settles SEC Fraud Charges by yourbandsucks on Saturday September 29, 2018 @06:25PM (#18103265)
It's particularly relevant to Apollo considering Werner von Braun. In hindsight, it looks less urgent because we didn't do a lot with the intervening years.. but it could have been different.

Not sure why people downvoted my question, it's an interesting line of inquiry. Maybe they don't know their history.

Re:Elon Musk Settles SEC Fraud Charges by fooker on Sunday September 30, 2018 @10:01AM (#18106190)
People downvoted your question because they don't like counterexamples conflicting with their ideals.