One of the many points of automated testing is that it's automated. I don't have to mentally run all of my tests in the back of my head to tell whether or not my code is correct. With this setup, I do. I become scared to even hit Ctrl+S in case I made a typo somewhere. Or perhaps even worse, what if I made a typo in my test and just committed a half-finished implementation? I've taken automated testing, one of the most brilliant time-saving inventions in all of programming, and turned it into a chore.
And as a programmer, that's supposed to encourage me to do more TDD?
I understand that the article is specifically about addressing those kinds of doubts, but... I dunno. I can't imagine ever trying this for any program bigger than a couple thousand lines of code.
If the goal is to have tiny changes, why not just count up the changelog and revert it if anyone ever tries to commit more than 25 lines of code? It seems like that would be just as effective, and potentially less annoying.
I'm sure your (manual) commits keep together the changes to the code and the matching changes to the test that keep the test green—but your Ctrl+S'es probably don't. In this strange workflow, the tests are required to be green every time you press Ctrl+S; and any time you press Ctrl+S and the tests aren't green, everything you did since the last time the tests were green disappears from the worktree.