In short, I'm not impressed by gross profits (Revenue - COGS), but I agree with the Tesla Bulls that operating-profits (Revenue - COGS - SG&A - CapEx - R&D) is too strict.
My definition of Tesla sustainability is (Revenue - COGS - SG&A). EDIT: Seems like this value is called "Operating Income".
That is explicitly what would please me. SG&A (Sales, General, and Administrative) costs MUST be accounted for because Tesla decided to avoid dealerships. So all sales staff employed by Tesla need to be accounted, if you are planning to build a sustainable company at a sustainable price.
> It is time for Tesla skeptics to admit that they were wrong and recognize the sheer audacity of Tesla's achievements. It is time to admit defeat.
As soon as Tesla reaches positive "Operating Income" (Revenue - COGS - SG&A) for more than one quarter, I'll gladly admit that I was wrong. Sound fair?
But that's what makes these misses so important. Elon Musk originally promised exponential growth with 20,000 cars a month by Dec 2017. But that's a miss. He pushed it to 5000/week by Q3 2018, and now it seems like that's a miss as well.
So Tesla, as a growing company, is nearly a year late on its rampup plans. As such, it may not have enough profits to pay down its first major $1-billionish loan due March 2019.
---------
That's what people need to be watching: how does Tesla plan to pay off $1 Billion loan (its also a convertible bond, so if the Stock Market raises the price of Tesla to $360, they can give stock instead of paying off the loan.)
THAT's why it was important to get 5000/week by December 2017 as Elon Musk originally tweeted: https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/881757617416056832
The runway has run-out. Elon Musk needs to raise capital to pay off the 2019 Billion $$ loan now.