Re:Gene drive used to turn all female mosquitos sterile
by emtel on Friday September 28, 2018 @12:48PM
(#18094839)
What you're saying is horrific. If you think population control is important, birth control, sex education, economic opportunities, and women's rights are the answers. Letting other people die in misery (that you'll conveniently never have to witness) due to some half thought out idea about what might happen in hundreds of years is literally evil.
Re:Gene drive used to turn all female mosquitos sterile
by athenot on Friday September 28, 2018 @10:57AM
(#18093876)
> I'm sure plenty of you will think that what I have said here is evil (even I feel that way a little bit)
Yes. It is. Because it relies on the premise of determining whether other fellow humans are worthy of life.
Re:Gene drive used to turn all female mosquitos sterile
by JamesBarney on Friday September 28, 2018 @12:40PM
(#18094758)
Imagine applying this same logic to justify letting your neighbor's child get hit by a bus....
But there is also some pretty good evidence that as child mortality decreases, the number of children parents choose to have drops as well.
Re:Gene drive used to turn all female mosquitos sterile
by camjohnson26 on Friday September 28, 2018 @02:38PM
(#18095857)
And this is where eugenics and Nazi ideology comes from. The American universities of the pre 1940s provided the intellectual foundation that Hitler built on. Most of them made arguments similar to yours and it led to some of the most horrifying events of the century.
Avoiding these millions of deaths per year will just increase populations in parts of the world where resources are already scarce. It could lead to ecological collapse, which very well could result in more human death all-at-once than the Mosquitos were causing over time.
Now, I hate to advocate for letting people die - that's obviously something we as a species aren't going to do - but I feel like we care about population control for every single species but ourselves.
I worry that all of our modern medicine and championing of mother nature could eventually be our demise in the long-term, even if all of these things provide incredible benefits in the short-term.
We are, after all, just really smart animals. In any environment where a single species eliminates all threats to itself, it becomes the biggest threat to itself in terms of competing for resources. We are better at managing resources than any other species, but to a fault. Eventually we'll bite off more than we can chew.
I'm sure plenty of you will think that what I have said here is evil (even I feel that way a little bit), but I think that this really could be a credible threat to humanity ~200 year down the line.