Re:Drone Hobbyists Angered by Congress Ending the Aerial Wil...
by andybak on Friday September 28, 2018 @05:54PM
(#18097374)
A resource can be locally limited despite being globally (or universally) unlimited. Energy for example (to a certain degree)
Also I'm not sure "zero sum" is the same thing as "limited". The former imposes stricter requirements.
I'm sticking to my guns on this one.
Re:Drone Hobbyists Angered by Congress Ending the Aerial Wil...
by Jedd on Friday September 28, 2018 @06:05PM
(#18097436)
I can't consume all the available quiet and therefore prevent you from having any.
Re:Drone Hobbyists Angered by Congress Ending the Aerial Wil...
by andybak on Friday September 28, 2018 @08:26PM
(#18098030)
You can consume all the quiet in specific area at a specific time. If that's not a limited resource then nothing is.
Re:Drone Hobbyists Angered by Congress Ending the Aerial Wil...
by Jedd on Saturday September 29, 2018 @08:57AM
(#18100078)
> You can consume all the quiet in specific area at a specific time. If that's not a limited resource then nothing is.
a) I don't know how you'd measure 'all the quiet' to determine that I'd consumed all there was.
b) even if I did, it doesn't prevent you from consuming as much (up to all) of 'the quiet' as you wanted, too.
Which brings us back to why it's not a tragedy of the commons, and why the analogy doesn't work either.
Not to say I agree with your dubious attempt at bringing 'silence' into the fold of 'resource'.
When you start mining silence by the barrel from deep space, then we can start treating it as a commodity resource.