I think there's a joel spolsky article on inc.com about this, intrinsic vs. Extrinsic motivation.
I think the value is simply knowing that other people notice your work, trickling that praise up to management, and making it super-simple to submit such praise.
It would still be up to managers to look at the praise and do the right thing after.
However, if thats the case then it already is super simple to submit the praise...walk over to their desk/call them/ping them/email them...
I'm not sure if having a central repository of feedback is really what callmeed was getting at but it's what I've built with my small app so this was my line of thinking.
Have been meaning to do a Show HN post for awhile now.
'Love' (as we call the positive feedback) thru email which populates the webapp is a feature as well.
Needs some TLC but most of all, need to get the word out to see if there is a product here or not.
First thing that comes to mind reading this: this could totally be a fairly easy but popular startup
Base it on email to make it Posterous-easy. [email protected] sends an email to [email protected] and says "[email protected] did an aweosome job on her TPS reports. She rocks!" ... manager approves, praise can be redeemed for cash/products/paid vacation days ... morale goes up, retention goes up, productivity goes up. hr costs go down.
profit.