So the question is, how much will they make with their current strategy? I don't know enough about the relevant numbers to do anything more than speculate. But if I had to, I'd bet the super angels are better off focusing on finding big winners than they are worrying about valuations and quick returns.
But my point is that, over 6 years, you won't be able to get 10^6, or really anywhere near that, because: (1) That would require re-investing all your returns, and as PG mentioned most of them have to go back to your limited partners. (2) Even if you could re-invest all your returns, it would be impossible to maintain an average of 10x yearly with that much money.
So the super angels can't really expect to find phenomenal success by just looking for quick exits. They need big exits too. Which means caring more about finding winners and less about valuations.
It could be that if the angels are less certain of whether a company can balloon, they demand the more exact valuation in the theory of making that a x10 portfolio member..
You might invest $10M in a web-type startup this year, and $1B in a radical new solar panel manufacturing facility 2 years later that promises to halve the price of solar-watts, etc. It also assumes that everyone wants to reinvest 100% every year, you'd get some investors who would be happy to just make back the $20M they lost in another market, and not keep doubling down.
So, I think the model is sustainable for longer than you might first guess.
Very true, but this model doesn't seem sustainable to me, unless I greatly underestimate the number of companies that could provide that "quick 10x return" (or unless the amount of money invested remains small and constant year-to-year).
Imagine you start with $10M in investments this year and make 10x. To make the same return next year, you've gotta find enough companies capable of a 10x return to invest all $100M you now have. Should you succeed, the following year you'd have $1B to invest. In a very short amount of time, your limiting factor switches from the amount of money you have to invest to the number of quality companies you can find to invest in.
It seems their rate of return is going to significantly decrease, year after year, until they're forced to change their strategy to one more in line with what the VCs are doing.