News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple changes words in order to change the debate by guelo on Tuesday October 19, 2010 @05:13PM (#1808787)
The openness reaches the consumer via competition. There will be many Android offerings from many manufacturers with a thousand different configurations and offered by all the carriers. HTC vs Motorola vs Samsung vs LG, Tmobile vs ATT vs Sprint vs Verizon, all trying to outdo each other. The winner is the consumer, even the Apple consumer because the competition will keep Jobs raving mad and working hard.
Re:Apple changes words in order to change the debate by irons on Tuesday October 19, 2010 @05:30PM (#1808855)
If you want to make the claim that the carriers are likely to duke it out and deliver any net value to the end-user, you're going to have to make a much stronger case than handwaving about competition. We're already talking about wireless carriers, so the subject of market failure shouldn't be alien to your frame of reference.

The only material improvement I see in the last five years is the market power that Apple has managed to steal from them, which it's put to mostly-good use.

Until Google is willing to start throwing its weight around with the user experience, Android represents no net gain to my thinking. But Google can't even enforce minimal backward compatibility or timely updates to its hardware partners, and is now running actively in reverse, painting a smiley-face on the carriers' opening up their own balkanized app stores. How does that serve Android developers or users?

Re:Apple changes words in order to change the debate by guelo on Tuesday October 19, 2010 @05:41PM (#1808904)
Don't you think Apple "managed to steal" the AT&T deal because of AT&T's competition with Verizon?
Re:Apple changes words in order to change the debate by irons on Tuesday October 19, 2010 @05:51PM (#1808951)
My point is that the "competitive market" you'd applauding was designed by the carriers with the specific goal of preventing anyone from ever doing what Apple did.

That Apple was able to do it was marvelous, but it was also stupendously unlikely: a combination of the willingness to enter an unpromising market, the ability to pull it off, and the timing to convince a weakened Cingular to let them produce a phone without undue interference. It had never happened before, and Android doesn't make it more likely to happen again -- quite the opposite, really.

Re:Apple changes words in order to change the debate by guelo on Tuesday October 19, 2010 @06:09PM (#1809004)
So your argument is that the only company capable of creating competition is Apple. Strange.
Re:Apple changes words in order to change the debate by irons on Tuesday October 19, 2010 @06:46PM (#1809145)
My argument is that "Markets! Yay!" is not an argument. Most markets require some regulation, and some luck, to function optimally. This particular market needs more of both.
Re:Apple changes words in order to change the debate by wtallis on Tuesday October 19, 2010 @10:06PM (#1809663)
Google's strategy with Android is to surrender complete control to the carriers. This is a consequence of them using an open source license that doesn't have GPLv3 style protections to ensure continued openness. Apple is the only company that we have seen in recent years do anything to weaken the carrier oligopoly. They probably aren't the only ones who have tried, but they are the only ones who have succeeded publicly. Thus it is entirely fair to say that Apple is the only company capable of creating competition in this market, so far.
Re:Apple changes words in order to change the debate by silvestrov on Tuesday October 19, 2010 @05:29PM (#1808843)
Lookup http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oligopoly

There are very few carriers in the US and they all have the same motivation for locking the phones. The number of phone models don't matter.

Heck, why is there so little competition between ISPs and carriers in the US? Cheap 100 Mbit internet connection, anyone?

Re:Apple changes words in order to change the debate by brianpan on Tuesday October 19, 2010 @05:26PM (#1808832)
By this reasoning, Android being open is not an advantage. I gain just as much buying an iPhone. I think this is an interesting shift of the debate- does open really matter? Or more specifically, who does open benefit and who cares about open?
Re:Apple changes words in order to change the debate by slantyyz on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @12:20PM (#1811771)
The whole openness discussion is so little inside baseball to me, and I don't know that the consumer impact will be all that great. There's a point of diminishing returns when the consumer has -too- much choice. They will just get confused.

Of the millions who are buying smartphones from any company, I tend to think only a small percentage care about the types of things we love to debate here.

I would say that the main reasons for a consumer (and they vastly outnumber us nerds) to buy a smartphone are:

* make a call

* send/receive texts

* send/receive e-mails

* surf the web

* take pictures

* look pretty

* do the facebook

* have some sort of mapping/gps

* have some sort of handsfree

* have decent battery life

And guess what, just about --every-- smartphone out there will satisfy that wish list, and do a pretty damned good job of it.

Openness? Number of Apps? Closed environment? Jailbreaking? Rooting? Nitpicky UI details?

Only nerds care about that stuff.