News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Myth of Charter Schools by yummyfajitas on Tuesday October 19, 2010 @01:58PM (#1808026)
I phrased it that way on purpose, in response to this part of ktsmith's post:

"There's no need for teachers in that kind of a system since they aren't allowed to deviate from the scripts ...It's really depressing to see what some schools are resorting to to make AYP."

If DI isn't improving student achievement in some categories of student, I agree we should scrap it. If we don't know if it is doing so, we should conduct randomized trials to determine that. But that isn't the critique ktsmith is making.

Re:The Myth of Charter Schools by tptacek on Tuesday October 19, 2010 @02:10PM (#1808080)
I agree with you that 'ktsmith's argument is irrelevant; it is not really depressing to see students achieve in school simply because it turns the teacher's day into a drudgery.

I am wary of silver-bullet solutions like DI, though; not only might they not work, but they could also be just as damaging to classroom performance as teach-to-the-test standardized testing has been.

Re:The Myth of Charter Schools by ktsmith on Tuesday October 19, 2010 @02:25PM (#1808148)
> simply because it turns the teacher's day into a drudgery.

Those words were put into my mouth by yummyfajitas. My complaint with DI is that it focuses on repetition and memorization rather than comprehension. It's great that a child can see a word on a test and recognize it then bubble in the correct answer because then we have "achievement." It's result though is meaningless if the child doesn't know what the word means.