Hopefully you're not representative of people normally judging resumes. When you're unemployed, finding a job is probably the most important thing you can do. Making something pleasing to the eye can only help your efforts, as long as all the information is there.
There are so many posts on HN about A/B testing. I'd A/B test my resume if it were possible.
Go grab a LaTeX template, replace the filler with your own information, and get it down to one page.