News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: What is causing the recent sudden uproars against... by open-source-ux on Wednesday September 26, 2018 @03:43PM (#18079535)
"...they were the good guys and could be trusted"

I've said this before but Google is neither the 'good guy' or the 'bad guy'. They aren't there to look out for your best interests and we'd all be much better if we stop ascribing human qualities to gigantic corporations. And they have never been 'stewards of the internet'.

As for the recent uproar, well better late than never. The attitude of the tech community is incredibly hypocritical on matters of privacy.

Google has always tracked users on an industrial scale. That tracking now extends to schools where ChromeOS is in widespread use. Tracking school kids online behaviour even if that data is detached from individual accounts and aggregated in some way is simply indefensible in my view. The amount of pupil data stored on Google's servers must be simply staggering. But barely a peep from developers on this issue.

Next time developers rush to Google's defence, they should ask themselves: does a gigantic multi-billion corporation that tracks people on an industrial scale need to be defended?

Re:Ask HN: What is causing the recent sudden uproars against... by alexgmcm on Friday September 28, 2018 @03:41AM (#18091656)
Why is it indefensible?

Surely what matters is what they do with the data - if it's being used to improve their products and services then why is it bad?

Are there concrete examples of where they have abused this data?