News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ex-Google Employee Urges Lawmakers to Take on Company by Aunche on Wednesday September 26, 2018 @03:06PM (#18079226)
Objectively, Google is extending its services to a billion people while maintaining the status quo of censorship. Stopping Google from expanding to China is basically another form of censorship, which is wrong.
Re:Ex-Google Employee Urges Lawmakers to Take on Company by andrei_says_ on Wednesday September 26, 2018 @03:44PM (#18079551)
It amplifies censorship and creates and provides the tools for censorship, which tools will become available as a (hidden) switch everywhere else, including here.
Re:Ex-Google Employee Urges Lawmakers to Take on Company by jonathankoren on Wednesday September 26, 2018 @03:20PM (#18079343)
It’s not obviously wrong, nor is it objectively the same product since the censorship and surveillance makes it very different. It makes it a tool of control.

Governments routinely regulate exports as matter of policy. Lockheed would very much like to sell Taiwan (or really anyone and everyone) F-35s, but as a matter of government policy, it’s not allowed to, as it runs counter to the policies of the American government. This maybe censorship in a broad sense, but it certainly doesn’t make it prima facie wrong.

Re:Ex-Google Employee Urges Lawmakers to Take on Company by femiagbabiaka on Wednesday September 26, 2018 @04:41PM (#18080075)
Corporations aren't people and regulation isn't censorship.
Re:Ex-Google Employee Urges Lawmakers to Take on Company by cryoshon on Wednesday September 26, 2018 @03:38PM (#18079496)
taking initiative to participate in maintaining a malicious status quo is being malicious. google isn't being coerced here, they're volunteering to help with oppression.

put differently:

what do you call an accountant who sings up to perpetuate the status quo of a criminal enterprise by updating their books?

guilty.

but they were "just extending the services of accounting to a new organization while maintaining the status quo of criminality".

Re:Ex-Google Employee Urges Lawmakers to Take on Company by billfruit on Wednesday September 26, 2018 @04:26PM (#18079928)
US and Canada sell weapons and military equipment to Saudi Arabia. Sufficient moral outrage is hardly bandied about in the case of such deals.
Re:Ex-Google Employee Urges Lawmakers to Take on Company by cryoshon on Wednesday September 26, 2018 @08:24PM (#18081344)
actually there is an abundance of moral outrage with regard to these deals. it doesn't make the press. i'll give you one guess why.
Re:Ex-Google Employee Urges Lawmakers to Take on Company by int_19h on Wednesday September 26, 2018 @10:57PM (#18081833)
If another country wanted to sanction US for this reason, I'd be supportive of that, as an American resident.
Re:Ex-Google Employee Urges Lawmakers to Take on Company by Aunche on Wednesday September 26, 2018 @03:49PM (#18079595)
> what do you call an accountant who sings up to perpetuate the status quo of a criminal enterprise by updating their books?

The difference is that the accountant is necessary for the criminal enterprise. Google isn't necessary for a censorship state, since China more than capable of handling that on their own. A closer analogy is that Google is the line cook of the restaurant the mafia hangs out in.

Re:Ex-Google Employee Urges Lawmakers to Take on Company by kodablah on Wednesday September 26, 2018 @03:17PM (#18079309)
These are also common arguments against country-level sanctions as well. People have differing opinions on the subject, but that something helps both the people and the regime doesn't always mean taking the good with the bad is worth it. I agree that both Google cooperating w/ China is wrong and that government interference to prevent it is wrong.