This is very, very misleading. You know it’s very misleading, as shown by your next paragraph but plenty of people actually believe there was a time when Italians, Irish were not considered white. There wasn’t. There was a great deal of prejudice against non-Anglos, Nordics emphatically included but there was never legal discrimination against them authorised by legislation in any state or at a federal level. That’s not true for Black people or Asians, both East and South Asians.
The entire shifting boundaries of whiteness literature is based on trying to muddy the difference between whether people were central or liminal members of a group with the question of whether they were members of the group at all.
No, people who care about whiteness still exclude Jews.
So do most Hispanics, who are clearly outside of the sense of whiteness applicable in most common conversation contexts.
To be fair, the census has a separate question to distinguish Hispanics, which allows their data to be used, on that point, in a way which accords with the common usage, where race and ethnicity are more of a blend cover than two orthogonal ones. And it didn't do that with Jewish identity.
But these days it's not hard to find people who care intensely about white identity and see that they don't consider Jews part of the tribe.
The "I'm not racist, but ..." majority - which is the real driver of systemic racism - doesn't. In fact, so much so that "Judeo-Christian values" became the standard way to describe the culture of that crowd, and it's a formulation that is specifically intended to include Jews.
This is actually really interesting because in America the boundaries of who is "white" and who is not has constantly shifted from a social standpoint.
There was time that Italians, Jews and Irish were not considered white (as in Anglo-Saxon or Nordic white) but this obviously isn't the case today.
South East Asians will probably never be considered "white" socially because of skin tone and cultural differences, but I'd argue it might be more important to be considered "not-black" or "not-Hispanic" than anything in America.