Arguing about whether economic policies are racist is a purposeful distraction. As if screwing over poor black families is completely reasonable as long as you're also screwing over poor white families.
As soon as you make it about race, you divide the poor into separate groups who are nominally at odds with each other even though in practice they have the same interests (e.g. lower housing costs). Then they fight against each other instead of fighting together for lower housing costs. It's a divide and conquer strategy to preserve the status quo.
And outside of the US, it can be totally separated. In China, for example, many of the poor people are ethnic han.
The biggest indicator of future socioeconomic status is educational attainment. The biggest indicator of educational attainment is wealth.
> Where does the biggest source of material wealth typically come from? Housing!
> Was housing policy racist? Very explicitly so, even in the progressive Bay Area. See: redlining.
> Are some of the policies that stemmed from racism still on the books in major metropolitan areas? Yes! Many of these exact policies are what's keeping from more housing from being built right now!
What policies, you ask? Here's a few.
- Excessively large minimum lot sizes
- High setback requirements
- Very low height limits
- Very high car parking requirements
While many of these requirements sound reasonable on their face, they were in fact implemented to keep out PoC [1]. Now they're used by people on the top of the socioeconomic pyramid to keep those on the bottom out.
[1] Further reading: The Color of Law by Richard Rothstein
ex: "Poor African Americans are four times more likely than poor whites to live in the central city, and twenty five times more likely to live in high-poverty neighborhoods." https://www.urban.org/sites/default/files/publication/67111/...
2006 George W. Bush 2,859,768
2008 John McCain 2,677,820
2012 Mitt Romney 2,661,437
2016 Donald Trump: 2,841,005
vs. 2004 John Kerry 2,741,167
2008 Barack Obama 2,940,044
2012 Barack Obama 2,827,709
2018 Hillary Clinton 2,394,164
Doesn't seem covertly racist to me, but maybe I choose not to see it. It's bad enough on its face so no need to add racism really.
A: they don't like poor people
B: they don't want poor people living near them
C: they want to prop up home values and this would limit that
D: they feel comfortable speaking for cupertino as a whole, so probably a long time resident.
Cupertino is overwhelmingly asian, 63% vs 32% in the county. Cupertino is a very wealthy town (rank 11th nationally in its size range). I think it's completely understandable, without introducing race, that anyone in a wealthy town doesn't want poor people bringing down the neighborhood. (Not saying it is or isn't correct or moral.)
Also just want to point out that Cupertino is not urban.