News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Myth of Charter Schools by tptacek on Tuesday October 19, 2010 @01:24PM (#1807900)
Or, the opposite is true, and we need to spend wildly more to offset the fact that public policy can't fix the non-school factors at play. The average school apparently spends ~100k per student from k - 8. What's the lifetime dollar value of having someone complete high school with grade-level performance, as opposed to having the system give up on them? The average cost per year of keeping someone in prison is apparently $22000.
Re:The Myth of Charter Schools by RyanMcGreal on Tuesday October 19, 2010 @01:34PM (#1807942)
The billion-dollar policy question is whether it makes more sense to spend that money through the school system per se or through a broader social policy that aims more directly to ameliorate the socioeconomic factors affecting school performance.
Re:The Myth of Charter Schools by skorgu on Tuesday October 19, 2010 @01:47PM (#1807991)
Which of course leads to the questions of what that social policy would look like, how we could evaluate it and of course how to ensure that demand meets supply if it does work.
Re:The Myth of Charter Schools by yummyfajitas on Tuesday October 19, 2010 @01:49PM (#1807999)
The gap in earnings appears to be $9k/year, so amortized over a 47 year working career, that's about $200-286k (depending on whether you take a 4% or 2% discount rate).

http://www.learnmoreindiana.org/needtoknow/pages/valueofeduc...

As you say, education can increase achievement by 10-20%. Supposing we can get a 20% improvement in graduation rates, that would only be worth $57k/student to the population of future high school dropouts (and it would slightly harm those who don't dropout, but I'll ignore that). A quick google search suggests that about 8% of students drop out.

http://nces.ed.gov/fastfacts/display.asp?id=16

$57k x 20% x 8% = $900 (per student, over K-12).

If we spend more than $900 to increase graduation rates by 20%, we are wasting our money. If we could reduce dropout rates to 0%, it would be worth $22.9k/student (again, over 12 years).

[edit: fixed calculation.]

Re:The Myth of Charter Schools by tptacek on Tuesday October 19, 2010 @02:07PM (#1808072)
It does not follow from anything posted to this thread that education can only increase achievement by 10-20%. About the nearest thing to that you can say is that within the confines of the current system, the best teachers inside of it appear to be able to improve performance by 10-20%. But as the article and the movie notes, there are charters that spend 3x that and get dramatically better results.

The point that the article is making is that it damages the argument against teacher union lock-in to observe that the best teachers in the public school system can only produce a 10-20% bump, because it implies that the free-market hiring practices of charter schools won't solve the core problem. Meanwhile, 50% of all teachers, including (one assumes) several good ones, are leaving the profession early because conditions suck.

Re:The Myth of Charter Schools by yummyfajitas on Tuesday October 19, 2010 @02:18PM (#1808114)
Let me repeat: "If we could reduce dropout rates to 0%, it would be worth $22.9k/student (again, over 12 years)."

Suppose a student costs $8k/year. If spend 3x more to reduce dropout rates to 0%, and we achieve the hypothesized increase in income, we are wasting $170k per student (i.e., we are spending an extra $192k to avoid a $22k loss).

Re:The Myth of Charter Schools by tptacek on Tuesday October 19, 2010 @02:26PM (#1808153)
The gap between high school grads and college grads without advanced degrees is ~$22k. What percentage of students that make it through high school successfully will then go on to college? It isn't 0%.

This also assumes that the educational buckets are "drop out, high school, college, and advanced degree". What do you think happens if we substitute "college" with "trade school"? What percentage of students will learn a formal trade if they complete high school that wouldn't if they had to get a GED first?

You also ignore the externalities of high school drop-outs; for instance, what percentage of high school drop-outs end up in prison? Note also that juvenile prisons are spectacularly more expensive than adult prisons. Are you hoping to stipulate that the burden to society of supporting drop-outs is wash against the competitive advantages given to people who complete school?

Re:The Myth of Charter Schools by yummyfajitas on Tuesday October 19, 2010 @02:54PM (#1808276)
Somehow, I suspect the people who would drop out of high school unless $24k/year is spent on their education are not going to college. I'd be willing to bet that the tiny fraction who do don't give $170k/student worth of benefits. If you want to propose spending lots of money, there should be lots of potential upside, and I'm just not seeing it.

Also, I suspect that yes, the benefits of having these people graduate high school is a wash. Currently, a high school degree is a signal that you are not dealing with the utter dregs of society and that the student can do what they are told for 12 years. If we spend $16k/year graduating everyone, a high school degree will be a signal that if an employer is willing to devote $16k/year to supervising the employee, they might be able to get some useful low skill labor out of them.

As for your theory of poor kids dropping out and then going bad/getting arrested, it just doesn't fit my experience. At the school I dropped out of, the kids were carrying metal long before they dropped out, and there was nothing that Dangerous Minds could do for them.

Look, I haven't worked out all the numbers. I've just a feel for the orders of magnitude. If you want to "spend 3x more", we will spend more on education than we spend on SS, Medicare and the military combined. I don't see any remotely reasonable way that the benefits would exceed this cost. But feel free to post your own numbers.

[Edit: just noticed I used a slang term. "Dangerous Minds" is a mocking term for nice liberal white girls trying to save their students. http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0112792/ (Also usable as a verb.)]

Re:The Myth of Charter Schools by tptacek on Tuesday October 19, 2010 @06:44PM (#1809135)
We certainly don't need to spend 3x more across the board. My kids' public schools are great; 70+% of Americans seem to believe the same.

However, we may need to triple what we're spending to teach kids in Englewood, or Harlem, or Oakland.

If we could add 100-200bn to education spending to triple the resources allocated to the bottom 10% of school systems, that might very well be worth it: those students are disproportionately likely to benefit from that spending, earn hundreds of thousands of dollars more throughout their life, secure jobs that include health insurance, avoid expensive prison terms, and draw less on welfare.