If my 1Password vault is breached, I am pretty much in a world of trouble as it is.
I have to remember three passwords (oh no!) and feel safer for it. It could all be in my head, though.
I use Authy to manage my 2FA codes, but I rarely ever use the desktop app. I stick to my phone to keep a physical separation between my logins and my 2FA app.
I also started storing my backup codes as a base64 encoded gpg password encrypted text file in my password manager. If I ever lose my 2FA codes I can still get into my accounts in a emergency while also protecting myself from a password manager hack.
It's annoying, but as I said, I'm not willing to take the risk.
Convenience is the enemy of security. I think you're making a good choice though. It's a minor inconvenience for increased security and peace of mind.
If someone gets into your 1Password it’s all over anyway.
That said, I pay for the standalone app and store my vault myself. I have no actual reason not to trust AgileBits hosting it, but they must be a huge target and I’m not taking my chances.
I used to be a Keychain + Authy user but moved everything to 1Password.