Re:Google CEO Sundar Pichai to Meet with Top GOP Lawmakers
by yongjik on Tuesday September 25, 2018 @03:51PM
(#18069897)
First, I'm no fan of Trump and I think GOP is full of shit. Also IANAL.
But I don't think First Amendment protects Google, in principle. A corporation is not an individual, it's an artificial construction allowed by the society because its existence is useful to the society. It does not have human rights. And, frankly, I don't think Google's search results even qualify as "speech". (Again, IANAL.) You won't find a single Google employee (or executive) who will say "Yes, what you see on Google's search result represents my opinion."
Besides, it's the fucking job of the government to "complain" about what corporations do. The government complains when a company overworks workers, pollutes a stream, or exercise their right to free speech by saying "This product is safe for baby!" when the government decides it is not.
We can talk about whether this particular case is justified: reducing it into a 1st amendment issue is not very productive, IMHO.
But I don't think First Amendment protects Google, in principle. A corporation is not an individual, it's an artificial construction allowed by the society because its existence is useful to the society. It does not have human rights. And, frankly, I don't think Google's search results even qualify as "speech". (Again, IANAL.) You won't find a single Google employee (or executive) who will say "Yes, what you see on Google's search result represents my opinion."
Besides, it's the fucking job of the government to "complain" about what corporations do. The government complains when a company overworks workers, pollutes a stream, or exercise their right to free speech by saying "This product is safe for baby!" when the government decides it is not.
We can talk about whether this particular case is justified: reducing it into a 1st amendment issue is not very productive, IMHO.