Re:ITER Tokamak: First Plasma Through High-Fusion-Gain Deute...
by SkyMarshal on Tuesday September 25, 2018 @11:18AM
(#18067012)
Possibly, but itβs way too early to give up on fusion now, especially considering its benefits - clean fuel, clean byproducts, less risk of meltdown and similar disaster vs fission.
Re:ITER Tokamak: First Plasma Through High-Fusion-Gain Deute...
by pfdietz on Tuesday September 25, 2018 @05:13PM
(#18070522)
Actually, it's long past time to give up on fusion, at least DT fusion. It's been known since at least the 1980s it would have lousy power density. DT fusion's putative advantages don't make up for that, nor for its grave operating issues (frequent replacement of major components and serious reliability/repairability problems.)
That means it's inescapable that there will be losers, regardless of how much is invested. There's no guarantee that fusion will win this competition, and good reasons to think it won't. Fusion may well go into the bin (with lighter than air passenger aircraft, superconducting digital computers, and MHD coal powerplants) of technologies that just couldn't cut it.