News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:ITER Tokamak: First Plasma Through High-Fusion-Gain Deute... by pfdietz on Monday September 24, 2018 @05:23PM (#18061578)
Unfortunately, even with higher magnetic fields, DT fusion is unlikely to ever be practical. That's because the power density of the reactors is inherently limited by wall loading and minimum size considerations from neutron cross sections.

Look at the numbers. The power density of a PWR fission reactor core is 100 MW/m^3. If you consider the volume of the primary reactor vessel instead, it's 20 MW/m^3.

The power density of ITER is 0.05 MW/m^3 (counting gross fusion power). Even if you just include the volume of the plasma, it's 0.6 MW/m^3.

What about higher field concepts like MIT's ARC reactor? If you look at the paper on arxiv where details are given, the power density is 0.5 MW/m^3 -- 40 times worse than a PWR.

The low power density is devastating to the economic case for fusion. Magnetic fusion reactors will be complex, expensive things, with superconducting magnets, complex cooling systems, breeding blankets, heating and control systems. They will be much more expensive per unit mass or volume than a simple PWR reactor vessel. And much of that complex system will need to be periodically replaced due to neutron damage. If the power density is 40x worse they cannot possibly compete.

Yes, (SP)ARC is better than ITER. But ITER is so horribly bad that a reactor can be an order of magnitude better and still not have any real chance of competing.

Re:ITER Tokamak: First Plasma Through High-Fusion-Gain Deute... by tim333 on Tuesday September 25, 2018 @11:10PM (#18072422)
Well, from a 2016 article on ARC they say cost 4 to 5 billion USD, output to the grid 200MW, which is not competitive with existing reactors but that would be the first one producing power built, the designs may improve. (https://www.computerworld.com/article/3028113/sustainable-it...)
Re:ITER Tokamak: First Plasma Through High-Fusion-Gain Deute... by pas on Wednesday September 26, 2018 @06:43AM (#18074577)
Agreed. Aneutronic fusion is the end goal and the real prize in the fusion game, and we're very very far from that. Yet with just waiting for it, we'll never get closer.

And of course eventually clean (as in proper reprocessing/recycling) fission energy would be great too, but that again is stalled, largely due to nuclear armament proliferation concerns.

Re:ITER Tokamak: First Plasma Through High-Fusion-Gain Deute... by londons_explore on Wednesday September 26, 2018 @05:38AM (#18074287)
I don't see why the number of cubic meters matters?

If you give me a machine that outputs 50kilowatts, I'll happily give up a cubic meter of my house for it...

Re:ITER Tokamak: First Plasma Through High-Fusion-Gain Deute... by pfdietz on Wednesday September 26, 2018 @07:07AM (#18074678)
Because size (and complexity) directly correlate with cost. So unless fusion can enable cost reduction elsewhere, if the nuclear island is inherently larger, more complex, and hence more expensive than in a fission plant, power from it will be more expensive than from a fission plant. And in that case, why would any utility want one? New and risky (in the sense of having a significant chance of not working as well as hoped) technologies like fusion will be adopted only if they are significantly less expensive than more proven alternatives.

The size and complexity also directly affect reliability. There is more to go wrong in a fusion reactor than in a fission reactor, and repairing anything there will be difficult because hands-on work will be impossible.