Re:“The Riemann Hypothesis” by Michael Atiyah – Preprint
by m00n on Monday September 24, 2018 @06:49AM
(#18056579)
You're right, I was thinking about univariate polynomials. The "preprint" is only concerned with functions of one complex argument, so this should suffice.
Re:“The Riemann Hypothesis” by Michael Atiyah – Preprint
by wbl on Monday September 24, 2018 @06:37AM
(#18056509)
C is not R^2. Neither f nor g is a polynomial over C, which is why they aren't a counterexample.
Re:“The Riemann Hypothesis” by Michael Atiyah – Preprint
by marcinmozejko on Monday September 24, 2018 @08:24AM
(#18057076)
And x = 0 is not an open set.
Consider f(x, y) := xy and g(x, y) := xy^2
Fixing x=0 note that f and g agree along {(x, y) | x = 0, y in R}. But f is not identical to g. There is no open subset of R^2 such that f and g agree throughout the subset.
Would rewording "two polynomials that agree on infinitely many points are identical" as "two polynomials that agree on any open set" fix this? Or restrict the statement to polynomials in one variable only?