Re:558M-year-old fossils identified as oldest known animal
by sofal on Sunday September 23, 2018 @05:37PM
(#18053391)
I’m saying that teleology without a mind(s) to hold the purpose is not a coherent concept because purpose is not an intrinsic property of objects. Even if it was a coherent concept, you seem to have decided that it is unfalsifiable, and for some reason you think that makes it rational to believe in. Do you think that all unfalsifiable ideas are perfectly rational to believe in merely because by definition they can’t be proven wrong?
Re:558M-year-old fossils identified as oldest known animal
by lisper on Sunday September 23, 2018 @06:21PM
(#18053618)
> purpose is not an intrinsic property of objects
Can you prove that? Can you falsify it?
> it is unfalsifiable, and for some reason you think that makes it rational to believe in
No, it is (at least potentially) rational to believe in it despite the fact that it is unfalsifiable, not because it is unfalsifiable.
We should merge this thread with:
That's right.
> Now you're saying that this God character doesn't follow from this "purpose" and that invoking that idea is suddenly a straw man outside of this discussion?
Yes, but you left out a very important caveat: I would restate this and add one word:
"... this God character doesn't necessarily follow from this "purpose" ..."
I'm not taking a position on whether or not God does follow from teleology, only that he might. Sorting out whether he does or not is a very thorny problem which is ridiculously beyond the scope of an HN comment.
All I'm saying is that, because God might follow from teleology, you cannot (rationally) dismiss out of hand someone who believes in God as being irrational no matter how irrational their conclusions may seem to you at first glance. Quantum mechanics is pretty frickin' bizarre too. It is possible that they have come to their beliefs in a perfectly rational manner, but starting from an assumption (like teleology) that you simply do not accept despite the fact that you can't actually prove that it is false, at least not rationally :-)