Re:High Performance Computing: Are We Just Getting Wrong Ans...
by jacquesm on Sunday September 23, 2018 @03:52PM
(#18052802)
If you think that is bad wait until you see biologists use software. They do not treat it as a black box, they treat it as a god. Obviously this will not hold for all biologists but the things I have seen horrify me that that is part of science. Output from complex pipelines of software is taken as gospel without any checking because ´who can check all of that´.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:High Performance Computing: Are We Just Getting Wrong Ans...
by nonbel on Sunday September 23, 2018 @05:47PM
(#18053443)
I've seen bio data get messed up just by one person opening a csv in excel:
https://genomebiology.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s13...
I mean not even editing anything, just opened the file to look at it and then allowed saving the file on close.
But yea, your typcial bio analysis is a lot of clicking around in one peice of software, importing that output into the next software, etc and is totally unreproducible. Then in the end you get an average and standard deviation (at least its not usually only p-values anymore) but no one ever checked what the underlying data looked like.
"Is your standard deviation for Group X so large because of low outliers, high outliers or is it a multimodal distribution?" "No idea. Whats a distribution?"