News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pythonist's thoughts on Clojure after 3 days of learning ... by j_baker on Monday October 18, 2010 @02:48PM (#1804615)
These are very valid criticisms, especially the error issue. That's probably my biggest gripe about clojure. The huge error tracebacks for trivial mistakes almost brings back memories of C++ templates.

I mentioned one of these particular instances on the mailing list once but didn't get any response. Perhaps it just isn't that big a deal once you work with the language a lot.

Re:Pythonist's thoughts on Clojure after 3 days of learning ... by fogus on Monday October 18, 2010 @03:28PM (#1804790)
It definitely is a big deal and I can't say for sure why your particular message was ignored -- maybe it was lost in the haze. In any case, there is an active effort to make error messages more coherent and will get better as time progresses.
Re:Pythonist's thoughts on Clojure after 3 days of learning ... by weavejester on Monday October 18, 2010 @07:55PM (#1805640)
There are a few libraries around (like clj-stacktrace) that significantly improve the quality of stack traces. There was some talk about integrating a library like that into clojure.core, but I'm not sure if any progress has been made on it.

It's a known issue, and definitely up there on the priority list to fix.

Re:Pythonist's thoughts on Clojure after 3 days of learning ... by sunkencity on Monday October 18, 2010 @03:27PM (#1804787)
The error messages are decent when working from emacs/slime I think. My major problem is that it's rather unpredictable what kind of exceptions that can be thrown where, makes it a bit hard to write defensive code. Other than that, I like it.