Re:NewSQL databases fail to guarantee consistency and I blam...
by ryanobjc on Friday September 21, 2018 @04:59PM
(#18042614)
I think this "global consensus with batching does everything partitioned does" is a very much theory vs practice type of statement. As in, in theory there is no difference between theory and practice :-)
I've seen those batched consensus systems, and honestly, you're kidding yourself if you think they can handle a million qps. Just transmit time of the data on ethernet would become an issue alone! Even with 40 gig - transmit time never becomes free. So now you're stuffing 1/10th of a million qps worth of data via a single set of machines (3, 5, 7, 9? Some relatively small amount)
Am I misunderstanding you? Hopefully I am!
To answer your question about scale: there is no real practical difference in scalability between the two categories discussed in the post. Partitioned consensus has better theoretical scalability, but I am not aware of any real-world workload that can not be handled by global consensus with batching.